Signed in as:
filler@godaddy.com
Signed in as:
filler@godaddy.com
by Oscar Leon November 15, 2019 for TRNN
The Colorado River system provides water for around 40 million people. A 25-year drought has endangered this system, prompting seven states and Mexico to accelerate conservation efforts.
NARRATOR: On January 1st, 2020, the Colorado River System will issue cuts in water supply to Arizona, Nevada and Mexico – areas that are already suffering from a 25-year drought.
The cuts are necessary steps for maintaining the sustainability of the Colorado River System, which is threatened by a complete collapse if nothing is done, and which would affect tens of millions of people .
NANCY J. SELOVER, Ph.D., ASU, SGSUP & Co-Chair, Drought Monitoring Tech Cmte: We’ve been in a drought, closer to 25 years since about 1994. We’ve had many, many more dry winters than wet winters.
NARRATOR: Nancy J. Selover is a State Climatologist and Co-State-Coordinator from the Arizona State Climate Office, as well as a Co-Chair of the Drought Monitoring Technical Committee.
NANCY J. SELOVER: If we continue with the drought, we’ve seen that [geologists] done studies that look and see in the past that we’ve had droughts as long as 60 years or more.
If that turns out to be what we have now, that is certainly going to be a problem. And so we are going to get to that point where we have, you know, the demand for water exceeds the supply. Potentially more than what we have at this point.”
NARRATOR: In the context of such a drought and uncertainty, the importance of the Colorado River System comes to the forefront. According to the U.S. Bureau of Reclamations:
“The Colorado River System (System) is composed of portions of seven States—Arizona, California, Colorado, Nevada, New Mexico, Utah, Wyoming and Mexico. 30 to 40 million people depend on the water delivered throughout the system. It is also estimated that about 4 million acres of agricultural land are irrigated with its water.”
Yet after 25 years of drought, the effects on the system are evident. There are two main threats to the Colorado system: One, that rivers and streams contributing to the river flow carry less water, due to less rain or snow; and two, that water from the reservoirs evaporates on days of extreme heat.
NANCY J. SELOVER: Arizona has been doing a lot of water banking, pumping water back underground in order to preserve it, so it doesn’t, it’s not sitting out in a lake evaporating.
NARRATOR: On Lake Mead, the minimum water level required to generate power at the Hoover Dam is 1,050 feet. “Dead Pool” is a term used to refer to the condition when the reservoir reaches the lowest water outlet of the Dam, at 895 feet. Anything under below that level that would mean no more water from the system for tens of millions of people. A study by the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation projected a level of 1,089 feet by January 1st. 2020.
In 2015 and 2016, the Lake Mead Hoover Dam System came near critical levels. Amid intense drought, water levels at Lake Mead reached 1,080 feet, a mere 30 feet from shutting down the electric generating plant. Conservation efforts ramped up after that.
We can see the effect of conservation in this graph. The black dotted line under the green area is where the water level would be, if not for a multi-state, bi-national concerted effort at water management.
This included voluntary contributions by members to leave water in the lake – which are represented in blue – also systemic conservation efforts – represented in red – and a couple of wet seasons, represented in Green. These factors turned around what otherwise would have been a negative trend.
SARAH PORTER, Director, Kyl Center for Water Policy, ASU: In 2017, we had a really wet spring and that helped a lot. And then last year, we had a lot of snow and that helped. So we had a little bit of weather that helped sort of “buy time” until the drought contingency plan could be implemented.
NARRATOR: Sarah Porter, is the Director of the Kyl Center for Water Policy, and the Morrison Institute For Public Policy from Arizona State University.
SARAH PORTER: In the last several years, the Colorado System States and Mexico have worked on with the federal manager, the US Bureau of Reclamation, on conserving water in Lake Mead, and that effort to conserve water has done a lot to keep levels of the lake up.
NARRATOR: In May 2019, the Drought Contingency Plan, or DCP, for the Upper and Lower Colorado River basins was signed between Colorado, Arizona, Nevada, New Mexico and California. In June 2019, a Bi-National DCP was signed between U.S.A. and Mexico, under these agreements Arizona will take a 6.7% cut, Nevada a 3% cut, and Mexico also a 3% cut.
Barring a dramatic event, the DCP would maintain the status quo in the river system until 2026, when all parties involved plan to re-evaluate and negotiate a new agreement.
SARAH PORTER: For the most part, management of water is highly technical. It’s not a political thing.
In the negotiation of the Drought Contingency Plan, there was a lot of disagreement and there was zealous advocacy by various stakeholders on, you know, for their needs. They fought hard and worked hard to hammer out an agreement.
NARRATOR: Profesor Selover warns of an overall trend for further warming and drought, which may force states to plan and adapt to much more difficult circumstances.
NANCY J. SELOVER: Drought is a normal thing, drought is a constant, it comes in and goes, right. How long it lasts varies, it can last a very, very long time, a little bit drier than normal or can last a short period of time a lot drier than normal and occasionally, a long time, a lot drier than normal.
Warmer temperatures tend to make mid elevation areas, 5800 feet, 6200 feet, those kinds of places have more potentially more of their winter precipitation fall as rain rather than snow.
Snow is our most important resource, in terms of water, because it stays on the land sitting there all winter long. And then finally in the spring, it gets melted and goes into the reservoir system.
NARRATOR: The close calls of 2015 and 2016, served as lessons about how fast things can change when a few years of drought and extreme temperatures are stringed together, a particularly frightening thought when facing a trend of warming temperatures.
by Oscar Leon February 2, 2019 for TRNN
In Tucson, Arizona, a US Magistrate handed guilty verdicts against four No More Deaths activists, who were leaving water for border crossers, along the US-Mexico border. The activist group calls the decision a retaliation for releasing an incriminating report about the Border Patrol. A fifth activist faces an upcoming trial and potentially decades in prison
NARRATOR: As part of the Trump administration’s ramping up of prosecution and anti immigration enforcement push, on January 18, four “No More Deaths” activists were found guilty of different charges. They were detained for being on Cabeza Prieta, a protected 860,000-acre refuge without a permit, and for trying to leave water for immigrants crossing the desert.
OSCAR LEON: We are outside the federal court building in Tucson, Arizona, where 4 NMD activists were prosecuted.NARRATOR: The group’s driver, Natalie Hoffman, was declared guilty of operating a vehicle in a wilderness area, entering federal land without a permit and abandonment of property, while Oona Holcomb, Madeline Huse and Zaachila Orozco-McCormick were found guilty of two of those charges.The defendants, who are still awaiting sentencing, face a maximum penalty of six months in prison and a $250 fine each.CATHERINE GAFFNEY: The prosecution’s call into question both the right to receive humanitarian aid, which everyone has the tight to, regardless of your documentation status. Everyone has the right to medical care and to food and water. “NARRATOR: Catherine Gaffney is an activist for No More Deaths, a multifaith coalition group and a ministry of the Unitarian Universalist Church of Tucson.She came as a volunteer and saw so much death and suffering that she moved to Tucson on 2011 to be a permanent volunteer for the organization.CATHERINE GAFFNEY: Doesn’t matter if you’re an immigrant or not. And it’s an attack on the right to give humanitarian aid, which is not only a human right, but it’s a principle of faith for people around the world.NARRATOR: Activist Scott Warren, who is an Arizona State University instructor, awaits trial for charges involving harboring undocumented immigrants, which is considered a felony.His detention happened just hours after the release of the videos of border patrol destroying water jugs.CATHERINE GAFFNEY: There is a pattern of targeting No More Deaths. These latest prosecutions really kicked off when we really started a report documenting thousands of incidents of border patrol destruction of water in the desert. So we believe there’s a pattern of retaliation here.
NARRATOR: Dan Millis, a former No More Deaths volunteer, was also found guilty of littering in 2008. The ruling was overturned by the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in 2010.DAN MILLIS: Max and I and a couple of different volunteers with No More Deaths, we were approached by federal law enforcement officers. And they said, “What are you doing here.” We said, “Well, we’re leaving water for people in need.”They said, “You can’t leave water because that’s littering.” And we said, “Littering? We’re not littering. We’re actually picking up garbage. If we find any garbage or trash on the ground we pick it up, and we put out fresh, clean bottles of sealed water and we keep track of it all. We write it down, we come back and check on it. And every time there’s an empty, we put a new one out and take the empty and recycle it.”NARRATOR: No More Deaths began in 2004 as a coalition of community and faith groups trying to stop the deaths in the desert, which have been documented to be as high as 160 a year.DAN MILLIS: In 2005, when Shaunti and Daniel were accused, they brought felony charges for again, I think it was a year and a half, two years. Those charges were finally dropped. Then I got prosecuted. My friend, Emeris Stanton, got prosecuted. Then Catherine Fergusson, who has since passed away.
NARRATOR: A third group of volunteers awaits for their trials on February 26. Caitlin Deighan, charged with driving in a wilderness area, along with Zoe Anderson, Logan Hollarsmith, and Rebecca Grossman-Richeimer, all charged with entering a national wildlife refuge without a permit.CATHERINE GAFFNEY: It’s simply not possible to carry the amount of water that you would need. There are no natural water sources in that desert. There’s two or three wildlife stock tanks with pretty polluted water that isn’t very healthy to drink. Often leads to diarrhea and GI problems.And on the day that the four volunteers were stopped by Fish and Wildlife, it was 110 degrees. So walking in 110-degree heat for three to five days with no natural water, it’s clear that that will mean death, if people aren’t able to find water to keep going.NARRATOR: Anybody who has been around the Sonoran Desert understands how deadly it is. Not only does it have extreme weather in day and night, but also a great number of cactus that can make your life very difficult. You can get lost or you can fall into a ditch, hurt yourself and be left to die.The main danger is the heat, and its chief assassin is a severe heat stroke.DAN MILLIS: In 2008, when some No More Deaths volunteers and I were walking through a remote canyon in The Arizona – Sonora borderlands, we came across the body of someone who had died trying to cross the border.And this person was actually very young. She was only 14 years old when she died, and her name was Joseline and she had been crossing from El Salvador, trying to reunite with her mother in LA.She had already traveled through Central America, through all of Mexico, and had come to the point in her journey where she was walking across the border with her little brother who was, I guess, 10 years old at the time. And they were being led by the coyote.She became sick, she couldn’t keep up with the group. She told her little brother to keep going and to reunite with their mother, which he was able to do. But no one ever saw Joseline alive again that we know of after that.We have actually been victorious in the courts in defending our humanitarian aid, since 2005, so we are going to continue with that success.Not only are human rights being violated but people are being killed. Whether they’re dying in our deserts, dying in detention, dying after they’ve been deported and delivered back into the hands of the gang members they’re trying to escape. It’s just murder and it’s wrong, just like slavery was wrong.CATHERINE GAFFNEY: What we saw this week was criminalization of being able to put out water in the West desert in a corridor where hundreds of people have died and countless more disappeared in the last five years.We’re really concerned by the judge’s ruling that seems to prohibit being able to put out water in an area where people are dying of thirst.We think that there should be respect to the preservation of life put ahead of targeting of humanitarian need by government. And what we’ve really seen in the West desert is a clear pattern of targeting with No More Deaths, specifically we saw them re-write their permit in 2016 to forbid human humanitarian aid on the Cabeza Prieta refuge.The policy of prevention through deterrents, which is the official border policy of the United States. It was adopted in 1994 when NAFTA was enacted and the strategy is to make the crossing through the border so deadly that it will deter people from migrating.It had not in any way deterred people who are fleeing for their lives from crossing through the desert. One of No More Death’s core demands is for an end to prevention through deterrents. It is the cause of the thousands, more than 7,000 lives lost on the border.
OSCAR LEóN: The verdict seems to confirm what many had feared: that the Trump administration is using the Arizona desert as a weapon. Deterrence by death.
For The Real News, from Tucson, Arizona, this is Oscar León.
by Oscar Leon June 19, 2019 for TRNN
In Arizona pro-immigrant and voter registration activists are being intimidated, both by the state and right-wing white-supremacy groups
NARRATOR: In Arizona, pro-immigrant and voting registration activists are being intimidated by both the state and right-wing white supremacy groups.TOMAS ROBLES JR, CO-EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, LUCHA: They chase us around and say we don’t belong here, they called us illegals, they said we are terrorists and traitors. We have gotten anonymous letters, from people who are too cowardly to write their names down, but will say that we are evil, that we are terrorists. We even had people call our phones, our private lines and say the same things.NARRATOR: Tomas Robles is a co-executive director for Lucha, an acronym for Living United for Change in Arizona, an NGO focused on constructing community political power.TOMAS ROBLES JR: So this has never happened under president Obama ‘s watch, it has all happened under 45’s administration.You could talk to the Obama Administration, you could plead to them. And you could create policies that could help some immigrants. Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals is one of them.With Trump you are seeing the opposite, you are seeing the caging of kids, 7 children have died in captivity, now he is ruining schools and English classes, and then he will turn around and say immigrants won’t learn English.NARRATOR: In the context of the Trump administration’s “war on immigrants,” the pressure has grown to new heights in many ways, and not only coming from the state of Arizona. This is Sebastian del Portilla, a young Community Organizer from Phoenix, Arizona.Sebastian del PortillaCommunity Organizer LUCHASEBASTIAN DEL PORTILLA: What we do every day, acting against our government and in the best interest of our community. It is dangerous, you are putting yourself out there. For authorities to come and beat you. Right? To be arrested to be harassed by white extremist groups.That type of people, right extremist groups have come by our offices before. With guns, trying to intimidate us.NARRATOR: Arizona’s sanctuary churches and Latino rights NGOs, volunteers, guests, and staff, have been verbally assaulted by right wing activists, who many times were trespassing on private property armed with guns.STEPHANIE MALDONADO, ORGANIZING DIRECTOR, LUCHA: I’ll say that under the Trump administration what we have seen is an increase in the ability to be bold. On the other side, we have seen lots of hate, we have seen individuals coming out, directly being racist towards communities.NARRATOR: Stephanie Maldonado is the Organizing Director of LUCHA. Her mother self-deported in 2012 under the shade of the infamous SB1070 law and the crude enforcement of similar laws that followed.Stephanie then felt the need to join with like-minded individuals and defend the local Latino Community, many of whom like her had lost so much, due to this now ramped-up “war on immigrants.”STEPHANIE MALDONADO: I think that when Obama was president, I mean, that was happening, but it wasn’t as acceptable to say “go back to your own country.”What changed more so now is that individuals feels a sense of privilege, to be able to be racist towards communities of color.NARRATOR: These are serious threats, so much that the Southern Law Poverty Center and a large group of local churches, many of them sanctuaries, filed a federal lawsuit against the AZ Patriot Movement and AZ Patriots, 2 white supremacist groups, which have been classified by the center as hate groups.According to the lawsuit, these anti-immigrant organizations have trespassed into churches and sanctuary churches, posing as media or volunteers, to confront, harass and disturb immigrants, church staff and volunteers.The lawsuit names several members of each group as responsible for defamation, trespassing, invasion of privacy, discriminatory interference with property, and conspiracy to violate their civil rights. One of the defendants, Antonio Foreman, even attended the infamous “Unite the Right” Rally in Virginia, where Heather Heyer was killed by a white nationalist, and many more were injured.TOMAS ROBLES JR: We see mass shooting everywhere. It is always a white man. It is almost always a white man. And we see these groups like the AZ Patriot Movement, they are all white Americans who terrorize young brown Americans. And have no kind of shame in doing so. These are terrorist groups.You could see another thing that happened in Oregon a couple years ago, where they held a government building hostage with guns, and they got no jail time. Whereas you had seen any black or brown people doing that, they would have been shot and killed.NARRATOR: The U.S. Government has also increased its efforts against activists, from the leaked Homeland Security Secret Database, tracking not only pro immigrant activists, but also lawyers and journalists.To the charges against Dr. Scott Warren, seeking 20 years of prison, for allegedly feeding and giving water to groups of immigrants crossing the deadly desert. In Warren’s trial, the jury was not able to reach a verdict, according to The Tucson Sentinel, it was declared a “hung jury” and prosecution reserves the right to star over with a new trial.The pressure has increased across the board nationwide. In Texas, Teresa Todd, a county attorney for Jeff Davis County, who saved the life of 3 siblings in extreme distress, was charged with harbouring illegal aliens, and like Dr. Warren, she also faces 20 years in prison.Both cases respond to a Trump administration directive to focus on the “harboring status,” which is applied broadly, even in extreme cases, such as this one, where Todd was allegedly following one of the most basic human impulses: to save the life of 3 children.SEBASTIAN DEL PORTILLA: What has happened with Scott Warren, him facing 20 years, and the fact that there is, you know, militia groups out there in the same area doing what knows what to immigrants in the desert, sends a clear message that our government clearly does not prioritize people of color and immigrants in our communities.Our current political environment and the history of politics here in Arizona, has been one full of white supremacy and with inequity. So for folks that are mixed status, living here undocumented, there is a huge fear in our community.NARRATOR: Stay tuned with The Real News for more on the issue.
by Oscar Leon September 15, 2019 for TRNN
ITohono O’odham Nation Members voice their objections to Trump’s border wall and the disruption of the lives of the people and animals that have lived there for centuries
VO: President Trump’s border wall appears to be moving forward, at a great cost to many. One group that is bearing this cost are the members of O’odham Nation. They are calling attention to the disruption of their lives, of their sacred places, and of animal migration routes that have been in use for centuries.According to a Federal Government’s lawsuit to oppose delays in the completion of the border barrier, 44 miles of the 30-foot high border wall will be constructed in the Organ Pipe Cactus National Monument, Cabeza Prieta National Wildlife Refuge, and San Pedro Riparian conservation area, which are Unesco-recognized biosphere reserves.To find out how this project will affect native border communities and the ecosystem, we visited the town of Ajo, South Arizona. From there, a group of local native activists guided us to a small pond called Quitobaquito, inside the Tohono O’odham Nation in the Organ Pipe Cactus National Monument, an area where the border wall is currently being upgraded and expanded.Oscar LeonTRNN“This is the Quitobaquito area in Ajo Arizona. That right there, it’s Mexico.And this right here is the old wall. They have, as we can see, it’s just a vehicle barrier. So trucks and cars can’t cross. But it does allow for animals to go under, across the border, for example to that water source we saw over there.”VO: Quitobaquito is an oasis in the middle of the Sonoran desert, where people and animals have stopped, to drink from the pond and refresh in the shade, for centuries. It is a place where temperatures easily average 110 degrees Fahrenheit or more during the day, and as we later measured, 100 degrees Fahrenheit at night.Amber OrtegaTohono O’odham Nation“Right here is where we have the border, the border barrier between the United States and Mexico, and right here is Quitobaquito.So, this is 150 yards, this land that you see, the space you see is what they want to clear, in order to create this renovated wall and it would interrupt the life of the spring.And it also like, the fear that we Hia Ced people have, is that it would not only interrupt the natural spring, but it would deplete, the drilling of… the drilling for the wells to complete the wall, would definitely interrupt the natural flow and life of this spring.And us as Hia Ced people, we will not be alive we would not be here, if it had I’ve been for this spring, this spring is what provided the people, [with] water to irrigate their crops.It’s what provided the people with water to build.”VO: That could be a reason why, in this area, the border wall was just a small fence that allowed for people and animals to cross the border. The local wildlife includes javelina, coyotes, mountain lions, pronghorn sheep, owls, hawks, and 270 other species of birds and plants, including the magnificent Saguaros cactus.Ortega and David both contend that to bulldoze a 150-foot corridor next to the wall, could irreparably affect the ecosystem of the area.Nellie Jo DavidO’odham Anti-Border Collective, Juris Doctorate“This particular body of water is a sacred spring, for Hia Ced O’odham water is life and this spring has been the life, for plants, animals, all desert life and Hia Ced O’odham people.It’s how our people survived out here and you know this very dry land, this is the one source of water that we would have.But even drilling anywhere near Quitobaquito springs, it is a desecration to us, as Hia Ced O’odham people and to the land.”VO: In fact, in this map provided by the Center for Biological Diversity, we can see the importance of Quitobaquito.It is the only source in the area not only for water, but also for fish and potential hunting grounds, catching animals that are trying to drink.For a nomadic group this would be the center of daily life. Now the area will be literally cut in half and all the animals in the southern area may face dire consequences.Nellie Jo DavidO’odham Anti-Border Collective, Juris Doctorate“We saw, you know, before we came here, we saw plenty of footprints of animals.And so it’s still very apparent that all of this all of the animals around here depend on this spring as as its life source.And with Trump’s imminent wall, they started over in Lukeille and they’re working their way down here as we speak. And they’re not you know, though they’re not there yet.But even drilling anywhere near Quitobaquito springs, it is a desecration to us, as Hia Ced O’odham people and to the land.”Amber OrtegaTohono O’Odham Nation“It is frustrating to know that this is part of colonization and the classification part of genocide. This is part of corporate America.You know, for us here, it is not about the next president. It’s not about policies, it’s about the land, it’s about the people. It’s about the history. It’s about the future, our future generations.”VO: Ofelia Rivas is an elder of the Tohono O’odham Nation. She lives a couple hundred yards from the border, so she has seen the buildup of border enforcement up close.Ofelia RivasTohono O’odham Elder“you know, the, because of Trump and really fast tracking the border, putting up the wall, and his all the funds that’s been diverted to build this wall. It affected us in a way that all these areas can collapse.In part 2 of this story, we’ll review the ultra modern surveillance system being used at the border. Stay with The Real News for more on this issue.
By Oscar Leon, August 12, 2019 for TRNN
After a week that featured an anti-immigrant massacre and a large-scale ICE raid, which fractured hundreds of families, the latino community is experiencing anger, fear and uncertainty
OSCAR LEÓN This week the Latino community was shaken by two acts of terror. The first was the massacre at El Paso, on Saturday Aug the 3rd. When a gunman opened fire and killed 22 people. Purposely targeting “Latinos”, according to his own words.
But the shock and awe for the Latino Community did not end there. On Wednesday August 7, Immigration Customs Enforcement, or ICE conducted raids on six different cities in Mississippi, leaving a distraught community in its wake.
MAGDALENA GOMEZ GREGORIO I need my dad by me. My dad didn’t do nothing, he’s not a criminal or something. Immigration took him. Please let him free (cries).
OSCAR LEÓN The anger at the various images of broken families and traumatized children quickly spread.
JASON COOKER Nobody’s safer in Mississippi. Nobody’s better off. What happened with these raids devastated hard working families that are trying to do their best.
FATHER JERRY TOBIN This is unconscionable. We have an agency that was created after 2001, called ICE. It reminds me of the Gestapo. I’m old enough to remember the Gestapo. We got it here now. This is unacceptable.
OSCAR LEÓN Yet among the community of undocumented immigrants, more than anger it was fear that spread. According to an anonymous source, from a popular store among Latinos, business has been running slow all week, and fear seems to be the culprit. We spoke with several members of an unidentified community:
UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN I don’t think the community is more united now. I think it’s the opposite. They have hidden even more to avoid going out.
UNIDENTIFIED MAN The raid and massacre do influence people from Mexico and with Mexican blood. We are thinking twice before going to a store after what happened.
UNIDENTIFIED MAN 2 After what happened this week, we do feel insecure. After such a week, now you go shopping and can’t be sure if you are safe.
OSCAR LEÓN They also told us about a new wave of discrimination, by emboldened Trump supporters.
UNIDENTIFIED MAN 2 If we speak Spanish to each other, for example at work, they stare at us like, “What’s up with these two?” I mean, you can tell when people give you a racist stare.
UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN As a matter of fact in my school they have treated me bad because I spoke Spanish, and since I can’t speak english that good, sometimes I feel scared to speak Spanish. I fear they’ll bully me or tell me something mean because of my accent.
I try, but it feels ugly, because I have other classmates that are scared to speak english, because they think they will get bullied as well.
UNIDENTIFIED MAN 3 It feels bad, because there is discrimination. I also feel insecure, you can’t go shopping in peace. Imagine it, if you go to a store, there are not supposed to be any guns there. They think we are stealing their jobs, but I don’t think so. We are doing the jobs they don’t want to do.
UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN 2 I was at work, there they told us “we don’t want for you to speak Spanish”, because we were two Mexicans and we spoke Spanish to each other. We replied, “What are we supposed to speak. We only speak Spanish. We are learning english but we just got to this country.”
OSCAR LEÓN Follow The Real News for more on the issue.
by Oscar Leon December 20, 2019. for TRNN
The U.S. government wants to put a border wall through land that belongs to the Tohono O‘Odham Nation. Oscar Leon reports.
by Oscar Leon August 6, 2019. for TRNN
Immigrant communities and people of color in the US are highly suspicious of the Democratic Party. However, there is a group of young democratic politicians from members of these communities who are giving hope
by Oscar León August 21, 2019 for TRNN
An extreme heat wave is covering up to 13 U.S. states. Along with the homeless population, this particularly affects workers who work outdoors, leading to numerous heat exposure deaths this year alone
NARRATOR In the second week of August, 2019, a dangerous heat wave was declared as a public safety concern for 13 States from Kentucky to California with triple digit temperatures in areas where millions of people live.
According to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, NOAA, July, 2019 was the hottest month on record in over 100 years. Well, for most workers and students staying indoors was enough to repel the danger. For people working outside, the situation can turn pretty dire.
KC MCGRIFF Water, I need to keep water with me. Just keep it by my side. Cold water at that. I just can’t get the regular. You get a headache. You might even get nauseous. You might faint.
NARRATOR According to usa.gov, heat waves are high-pressure systems that create a cap trapping air in one place as it warms. The site says, “heat waves like this may be less exciting or dramatic than other natural disasters like tornadoes, hurricanes, flooding or even thunderstorms, but heat waves killed more people in the United States than all other weather-related disasters combined.”
OSCAR LEÓN It’s 110 degrees at 11:00 AM here in Phoenix, Arizona. I have been working for 15 minutes and I’m already sweating like crazy and I feeling short of breath.
UNNAMED 1 Drink plenty of water and then we go into any office building that allows us to sit in there and relax. But it’s very important to dress cool. I’ve seen some people where you don’t know if they’re dead or alive. Every time I get a chance I try to give someone water if I have an extra bottle of water.
NARRATOR Because Phoenix, Arizona is in the middle of the Sonoran desert, knowing what to do and being prepared can make the difference between a day on the job and a possible tragedy. The city knows this and makes preparations.
MARK HARTMAN Much of our life, the way our buildings are built, the way we move around our city is very much desert-adapted.
NARRATOR Mark Hartman is Chief Sustainability Officer at the City of Phoenix.
MARK HARTMAN One thing we have is a really, I think probably the best in the nation, a heat relief network. It’s 139 organizations that all participate in providing cooling centers and places for water distribution sites and things that people can go to if they need to cool down or even in the case of power outages and things like that, that people can have a place they can go to to get cool and stay cool.
NARRATOR This was a near record-setting week with an overall extreme excessive warning representing danger to everyone, which was broadly broadcasted over all local media. On Thursday, it was projected to reach 114 degrees, one degree shy of the records set four years ago and while it was broadcasted on Friday to fall below 110 Fahrenheit, we measured 113 at 3:30 PM.
OSCAR LEÓN “I felt dizzy. I felt a headache. I feel short of breath and I definitely realized that I needed to get out of the sun.”
NARRATOR According to a study by the County of Maricopa where Phoenix is located, over the last three years, there’s been a spike in deaths over the summer with 154 in 2016, 179 in 2017, and 182 in 2018.
CPT. DANNY GILE Brian, our our call volume definitely does spike in the summer for sure. Our call volume goes up tremendously because the heat does exasperate medical issues. Anybody who has a normal medical problem, be it the young, elderly, the homeless population, those problems are going to get affected with the heat.
NARRATOR Out of the local heat-related fatal cases, roughly 59% have been determined by the county to have been directly caused by heat. Surprisingly, according to the study, 82% of indoor deaths had an air conditioning unit present at the time of death and perhaps not so surprisingly, 60% of outdoor heat-related deaths occurred in an urban area where there are fewer trees and vegetation to help cool off the environment.
According to the report, 23% of heat-related deaths occurred on days for which an excessive heat warning has been issued. The account is still open for 2019, but so far there have been plenty of cases reported. Like Stephen [Ballin 00:04:11] , an AC technician who was working on an attic while the city was at an average of 107 degrees and after 30 minutes of being in the attic, he was found unresponsive, later declared dead on June 19, 2019.
More recently on Thursday, August 15, the news broke out that two managers of a senior home were convicted for the death of a 69-year-old senior under their care after the AC at the facility failed for two days and the house temperature was 94 degrees. The victim’s room was found to have been at 100 degrees for 48 hours.
MARK HARTMAN For us, heat is like a silent storm and we need to think about it that way and be recognizing. Our workers start sometimes at 4:00 and 5:00 AM. They’re starting early in the morning. Yeah, no I think it’s just changing the work times versus trying to say, “Oh, you only have to work half as hard because it’s a really hot day.”
NARRATOR Workdays that begin at 4:00 AM, that was what Casey had told us earlier.
KC MCGRIFF Exactly, why I’m leaving right now at 1:00 as to where you want to start at 6:00 to 2:00, 2:30, I’m not doing it. I’d rather come in at 5:00, the extra hour. If I could come at 4:00, I would be here at 4:00 to leave at 12:00.
NARRATOR The CDC warns that above 103 degrees of internal body temperature, it should be considered a medical emergency and one should call 9-1-1. Wherever you are, if you have work outside during a heatwave, remember a few tips from Arizona’s workers. Cover your body from the sun. Get yourself in the shade every chance you get. Wear light colors and wear a hat. Have an abundance of cold water available and drink abundantly every 20 to 30 minutes.
Plan your schedule. Start before the sun goes out. Reschedule if you have to. Do not work at peak temperature hours. Do not work for more than 20 minutes at a time. Take water and shade breaks. If you’ve witnessed someone falling victim of a heatstroke or fainting, provide water to drink and take the subject out of the sun to a cold area as soon as possible. Drink water the night before or hydrate very early if you’re going to be outside the next day.
MARK HARTMAN Most people say, “Oh, I’m sorry wrong. I can do it.” But you can’t combat heat. You need to actually properly cool and hydrate your body.
CPT. DANNY GILE Anytime you’re outside working in that kind of extreme heat, very dangerous because your body has trouble handling that heat. Especially if you’re not acclimatized to the area, especially if you’re not used to working outside.
NARRATOR Alerts have been set for the next week with another round of record setting temperatures predicted not only for Arizona, but for all of the country. Stay with Real News for more on this issue.
by Oscar León November 29, 2018 for TRNN
In the midst of a prolonged drought, Arizona’s cities have found ways to adapt to low water reserves and put tight water management programs in place, in order to ensure future reserves
NARRATOR: Climate change is most likely to impact us in many ways. Giant storms, fire, heat waves, floods, and droughts are some of the most visible threats. Southwestern states like Arizona are hit especially hard. However, city officials are finding ways to address the problem.
Currently, southwest states such as Arizona are in the midst of a prolonged drought. Amid an 18-year drought, the Colorado River’s water level is sinking and can no longer supply major urban areas.
According to the U.S. Drought Monitor, which started in the year 2000 as an interagency mandated effort to coordinate all related information into a single system, “Since 2000, Arizona is currently experiencing the longest duration of drought (D1-D4), which as of October 30th, 2018 has lasted 481 weeks beginning on August 18, 2009.”
KATHRYN SORENSEN: The scientists are telling us that because of climate change and rising temperatures, the Colorado basin is aridifying, it is becoming more arid. And we can expect in the future that the flows of the Colorado River will be diminished. That is not good, that is a really dire situation.
NARRATOR: The city of phoenix gets 60 percent of its water from the Salt and Verde rivers, but 40% of the city’s supply comes from the Colorado River.
KATHRYN SORENSEN: What we are doing now is that we are actually preparing not just for shortages on the Colorado River, because we know that is coming. We are preparing for worst case scenarios on the Colorado River.
NARRATOR: This is a paragraph from an official document from the City of Phoenix:
“The Colorado River is overallocated. The Lower Basin states of Arizona, California, and Nevada, as well as the Republic of Mexico, take more water out of Lake Mead than is returned to the system, creating a structural deficit.”
NARRATOR: According to the Bureau of reclamation, up to 40 million people depend on the Colorado River. It is estimated that a collapse of the system would affect almost 1 in every 8 inhabitants of the United States. This has even created some tension between a number of counties and cities, due to ever increasing demand, while Lake Powell Dam keeps hitting historic low water marks.
KATHRYN SORENSEN: I want to be clear about this: the Colorado River is in serious trouble. We know it is overallocated. We know we are in year 18 of a drought. We don’t know if it’s year 18 of an 18-year drought, which is what we hope, or if it’s year 18 of a 100-year megadrought, but we have to plan as if we are in it for the long haul.
NARRATOR: According to the City’s report: “The most recent Bureau of Reclamation projections show a 57 percent chance of shortage in 2020, rising to a 70 percent chance by 2022, and a 14 percent chance that Lake Mead will fall below elevation 1,025 feet, the third tier of shortage, by 2023.
Most alarmingly, the Bureau of Reclamation recently presented a chart that shows Lake Mead could hit 985 feet in elevation within four years. Elevation 985 feet constitutes deadpool in Lake Mead; below this elevation water cannot be released from the dam.”
Rose Davis, spokesperson for the Bureau of Reclamation, explains the importance of Arizona’s artificial water reserves.
ROSE DAVIS: Well, Hoover Dam was way ahead of its time in the 1930s, and it created Lake Mead. And later, Glen Canyon Dam created Lake Powell. And between these two reservoirs, they’re doing exactly what they’re supposed to in this long drought. They’ve captured the water from the good years before 2000, and this is what we’re living on, basically. If we didn’t have these dams in place, there wouldn’t be any runoff for the last couple of years and river would be a trickle.
NARRATOR: Six U.S. states and the north of Mexico receive water from these dams. A collapse to this system could cause unthinkable consequences.
In Phoenix, a city in the middle of the Sonoran Desert, the pressing need for water conservation defeated all political games long ago.
KATHRYN SORENSEN: You can’t live through one summer here in Phoenix without understanding at a very personal level how important water is. It is literally a matter of life and death. People who live in the desert value water, so it has been relatively easy for us to ensure that people take the steps they need to take.
NARRATOR: Among all the cement and the asphalt you still see green areas, green golf courses and parks, which are very hard to maintain at extreme temperatures of 110 degrees Fahrenheit or more. Having a grass area can turn into a luxury. Not only that, but KATR News reported that out of the top 7 cities with most pools nationwide, six are cities that are part of Phoenix Metropolitan area.
BILL TURNER: In the Phoenix Metropolitan area, vegetation has a cooling effect, especially during the daytime.
NARRATOR: Professor Bill Turner II is an American geographer, member of the National Academy of Sciences, and scholar at ASU.
BILL TURNER: For each individual household in the city, on average 70 percent is for outdoor usage, so that is to water your vegetation, or a swimming pool, or some combination thereof. It is using a great preponderance of water on average per residence in the metropolitan area.
NARRATOR: The City of Phoenix started working in the ‘80s on two main fronts. The first includes education, and the second is an economic negative incentive in the form of higher prices in the summer.
The City’s numbers show that back in 1970 grass was very common, in up to 75 percent of family homes. Today, according to the City’s Water Management Office, that number is close to 14 percent–a significant trend apace with the steady drought experienced by the state.
KATHRYN SORENSEN: Before we can allow growth, we have to prove to the state that we have a hundred years worth of water that is physically, legally, and financially available to us.
We cannot mine our groundwater supply. We have to find renewable water supplies, reuse our waste water, conserve.
NARRATOR: Phoenix has learned a lot about how to manage their water resources and preparing for future droughts, and can be a learning lesson for other cities that sooner rather than later will have to cope with the effects of climate change.
KATHRYN SORENSEN: Other cities that don’t have this kind of outlook are relatively less prepared for extreme events. Here in the desert we have long understood the value of water, we have long understood what it means to go without, so we have taken preparation after preparation, plan after plan to guard against that.
It would be easier and less expensive to move a relatively small amount of water from were it is today to where it needs to go in the future to meet demands in a desert city than it would be to move unbelievable vast amounts of water from places on the coast and river systems, were [flood water] has insidiously invaded.
NARRATOR: Just a few days after the recording of Ms. Sorensen’s interview, Hurricane Florence devastated many counties, pushing dams and water reservoirs to the brink.
Maggie Sauerhage, Environmental Protection Agency spokesperson, reported that during the crisis in North Carolina, 16 community water systems completely shut down, in addition to several publicly owned treatment plants that were nonoperational due to the floods.
KATHRYN SORENSEN: Other cities need to start looking at climate change in these terms. What are some of the worst things that can happen? What do we need to be prepared for? How can we make sure that we are building the right infrastructure? The right mindset, the right culture of conservation?
NARRATOR: It is clear that planning and resource management can get results, as evidenced by the desert city of Arizona, which is restricting water use by price and also culture, has reduced or controlled demands that would normally would be far greater.
This is a testimony to the effective management of underground water, imposed by these cities in their area of influence. It is also a testimony that with effective management and planning we can counter some of the scheduled climate-caused damage we seem to be heading towards.
by Oscar León October 1, 2019 for TRNN
In addition to the border wall, the federal government has set up an entire system of ultra-vigilance which can record and forensically review everything that happens in the border area, presenting serious concerns for members of the Tohono O’odham nation.
NARRATOR: The U.S. Government’s Border Security build-up, has been going on for 18 years now, affecting not only the Latino community, which has had to deal with the separation of families, the criminalization of communities, and with racial profiling, but it has also affected native American border communities.We spoke to Ofelia Rivas, a Tohono O’odham Elder, who lives in the area of Ajo, Arizona.Ofelia RivasTohono O’odham Elder“The powers that be, the government, can and will just waiver, any rights that we have today, and do what they want to do, which is to build a vehicle barrier, build a wall and build an Integrated Fixed Towers [system] on O’odham lands and sacred lands that we have.”NARRATOR: To compliment the border wall, the federal government has gradually constructed an entire system of ultra-vigilance, with different kinds of mobile sensors, cameras, radar units, microwave systems, surveillance drones, and an Integrated Fixed Towers Surveillance network, or ITF, patrolling the border region around the clock and feeding information to a control center. By using mobile high definition cameras, sensors and radar stations, the system can detect and track movement from many places simultaneously, giving its control room the ability to guide many ground teams at the same time and to use a host of technological resources and special cameras to track many subjects at the same time.Ofelia RivasTohono O’odham Elder“When the Border Patrol proposed these towers, they were calling them originally communication towers, oh, we can’t communicate with each other. So we’re going to put these towers up. And originally they were 200 feet tall and because of airplane regulations they reduced them to 180 feet tall, and they proposed 15 towers on O’odham nation land.”NARRATOR: Elbit Systems is installing the surveillance system on O’odham land. The Israeli company was awarded a $145 million contract to construct 53 ITF towers in Arizona’s southern border in 2014. According to the Jerusalem Times:“[It] will ‘be able to detect a single, walking, average- sized adult’ at a range of 5 miles [8 km.] to 7.5 miles [12 km.] during day or night, while sending close to real-time video footage back to agents manning a command post.” Jerusalem Times, March 2, 2014.Popular Mechanics describes the system’s accuracy:“Elbit’s system is so specific that it can determine whether an individual is carrying a backpack or a long-arm weapon.” Popular Mechanics, Jan 28, 2016In Ajo, Arizona, we spoke to a group of native community activists and inhabitants of the border area. According to most of them, this net of intensive surveillance has radically changed their lives in many ways.Adrian VegaAjo, AZ, local inhabitant“The border has changed, you know, used to be, you know, it has always been very open. When I was born and raised here, we used to jump in my grandfather’s struck, everyone’s kids. We’d go down to Mexico. And it was no big deal crossing the border. You know, it’s like normal stuff, like family.”NARRATOR: Everything changed after 9-11. The border became a national security issue, with all the might of the Federal Government behind it.Nellie Jo DavidTohono O’odham environmental activist“after 9/11 we saw the increase of checkpoints. We cannot enter or leave our lands without going through a checkpoint and being questioned on who we are and where we’re from. It’s ironic because a lot of the people doing the questioning are outsiders to our homeland, and yet the people that are originally from there are often harassed and questioned the most..”NARRATOR: Rivas, a Tohono O’odham Elder, described being attacked on the way home from a wedding, for refusing to speak english or to show her papers.Ofelia RivasTohono O’odham Elder“Since 9-11, there’s been a great difference, very aggressive, and attacking people. To to the point of, you know, injuring people, and killing people.”“I spoke in my language, so he pulled his pistol, and he put it at my head in front of my daughter, and my grandson and said that I would have to say whether I was a US citizen or a Mexican citizen. And I said I am Tohono O’Odham Nation.”NARRATOR: There have been many reported instances of violence that the border patrol has committed, including the running over an O’odham nation tribal member. This, along with constant surveillance, has damaged an historically cordial relationship between members of the O’odham nation and the Border Patrol.Ofelia RivasTohono O’odham ElderThe international border impacts our people, we are impacted by the policies, immigration policies, We are not immigrants ourselves, you know, in our, our oral history, we’ve been here since the beginning of time. But these policies have been violating our cultural rights, and our human rights. “NARRATOR: The Border Patrol has installed sensors all over the border area and is patrolling it using surveillance drones. Some locals told us that they were followed when they were taking a walk with their dogs. They also pointed out that they are required to carry their identification papers constantly, to avoid being detained or even deported.The ITFs are just one of many surveillance tools that the Border patrol uses. There are also Remote Video Surveillance Systems, Mobile Unattended Ground Sensors, Unattended Ground Radars, Mobile Vehicle Surveillance Systems, Agent Portable Surveillance System, surveillance drones, planes, helicopters and even high tech surveillance blimps.All of these systems can network and form a “virtual fence”, which, even if you manage to cross the wall that is being built in the area, would make it impossible to pass undetected, Many of these integrated systems can also record all the information in its coverage area, process it, identify subjects and retroactively review where they have been and who they have been with.According to a written assessment directed to congress by the Department of Homeland Security:“Wide area persistent surveillance camera systems, have the ability to surveil a specific region, in order to increase the opportunity to detect and observe activities, identify entities involved, and track events forward in real time or backwards forensically.”Speaking to The Real News Network, Bill Parrish, a reporter who wrote a story about the O’odham nation and Border Patrol for The Intercept, describes how this “virtual wall” affects border towns and neighborhoods.Bill ParrishReporter, The Intercept“Some are located right next to residential areas. So basically anything that anyone is doing living in those areas is going to be captured by these integrated fixed towers, which pipe images and other data back to Border Patrol command centers in southern Arizona.They have a back in time feature, sort of like a TiVo meets Google Earth kind of feature, where basically all the images and data are stored and can be pulled up across time, so the Border Patrol agents are able to monitor people’s movements over time, which is essentially what persistent surveillance means.”NARRATOR: During the production of last week’s report about the new border wall and the local ecosystem, a Real News team visited Quitobaquito springs for several hours. We filmed right next to the border, but until we got to a checkpoint, we weren’t approached or searched.It is very probable that the agents in charge of the surveillance system in the area, who were notified of our presence beforehand, knew exactly what we did, with whom and where.This kind of “omnipresence”, entails great power over the populations it covers. As a result, it presents many questions, especially if the government expands its use. Bill Parrish, writing for The Intercept, quotes Bobby Brown from Border Protection at Elbit Systems as saying:“Over time, we’ll expand not only to the northern border, but to the ports and harbors across the country,” Bobby Brown from Border Protection at Elbit SystemsDespite numerous voices of opposition within the O’odham nation, a March 22, 2019 meeting, of the Tohono O’odham council approved the construction of the towers, as a sign of support for Border Patrol, the War on Drugs, and, as reported by The LA Times, in the hope the wall will not be constructed in certain areas. This hope, however, seems misplaced, since the wall is scheduled to cover all of Arizona’s southern border.Rivas believes that something larger might also be at play. She describes a worldwide trend of taking native land and displacing native nations as a very real danger for the Tohono O’odham people.Ofelia RivasTohono O’odham Elder“They continue to funnel people through here, maybe it’s because they want the land of O’Odham nation.Trump did say that He was going to privatize all Indian lands. And that takes years of steps before they can get to that point to privatized all Indian land. And they’re also playing with the word of eminent domain. eminent domain.”Adrian Vega also of O’odham nation, born in Ajo, told us that there is a consistent rumor about eminent domain.Adrian VegaAjo Native“That’s always a question with the native lands in America, is, you know, is because the government feels they gave it to them, they probably feel they can take it back. And that’s a huge concern, you know, to native nations around here.”NARRATOR: Rivas finds the current situation of Central American immigrants to be similar to the infamous boarding system, which the US government imposed on native communities all over North America.Ofelia RivasTohono O’odham Elder“I don’t listen to the news because of the children dying in prisons, and the women getting raped or, you know, all this displacement of families, you know. And I mean, it reminds me of the boarding school system.My aunt who was probably 12, was removed from home and got sent to New Mexico early on, when boarding school happened.I was taken to Nevada for boarding school, so that … we understand that, and that is all we can do, send our prayers, because we know how the system works and what has happened to indigenous people here on this land.”NARRATOR: Stay tuned with The Real News Network for more on this issue.
by Oscar León Mar 19, 2017 for TRNN.
by Oscar León August 28, 2019 for TRNN
In the first part of this series we looked into how heatwaves place outdoor workers at extreme risk, in temperatures for which the human body is not prepared. Part two takes a closer look at a group that is most affected by heatwaves: homeless people
Homeless in the Heat Wave / PhoenixOn the first chapter of this series we looked into how heat waves affect workers who perform outdoors, and the potential dangers for those working under extreme temperatures, for which the human body is not prepared. In chapter two, we will look into the group that is most affected by heat waves, homeless people.By Oscar LeonDuring the second week of August 2019, temperatures broke records worldwide, with forest fires raging from the Amazon to Siberia. Also, ice melted at a record pace in Greenland, and there were intense heat waves in the U.S., Europe, and Asia.July was the hottest month ever recorded.Cities such as Phoenix, Arizona, account for hundreds of heat related deaths every year. Last year 182 people lost their lives in heat-related incidents. This summer, (2019) by the end of June, with 2 more months to go, (according to Maricopa County) there have been 160 heat related deaths, and the count is still open.However, most heat-related deaths, around 40% of the total, are of homeless people, the group most at risk.Cpt. Danny GilePhoenix Fire Department“The homeless are a big issue, in Phoenix we have a large population, and like I said if you have no place to go, no place to live, and you are out in the hot asphalt, the hot concrete all day, it just expands on the problems we talked about, so it makes heat very difficult to deal with, as a homeless person here in Arizona.They struggle.”On August 21st, I visited downtown Phoenix. As I approached the city, temperatures went from 104 fahrenheit at 9:45am, to 108 at 10:30am, to 114 at 3pm.In cities around the world, when heatwave alerts are declared, they warn of temperatures often in the 90’s.The human body is designed to work at an internal temperature of 99 degrees fahrenheit. If the body reaches over 100 degrees, it should be considered Hyperthermia, which can lead to a number of consequences, including heat stroke, and should be treated as a medical emergency, to prevent disability or even death.SamHomeless, 50 years old“If you stay here you have to be kind of used to, but if you are not used to and you come here, it will just drop you. One day is ok, the next day, you just feel like, I don’t know like all the water has been taken out of you. You drink water all day and you don’t go to the bathroom, you just sweat.”“Sam”, asked for us to protect his privacy, He told us how hard and cruel life in the streets can be.SamHomeless, 50 years old“I have a friend, he was… everybody thought he was going crazy, but it was the heat. And next thing you know, they said he died of cancer, I thought there was something wrong with him, next day he couldn’t wake up and he was dead. A lot of people die out here because of the heat, they can’t get no water.”To think that human beings, designed to work at internal temperature of 99 degrees, have to endure 110+ fahrenheit degrees of temperature, for weeks at a time, it is mind-boggling, especially because it feels unbearable, even for a few minutes.Oscar LeonTRNN“I was doing a number of interviews in there, at 11am, at 109 fahrenheit, my camera overheated and stopped working, and that just goes to show how extreme the conditions are here.”VO: On 11th Avenue in downtown Phoenix, there are two shelters across the street from each other, providing relief to many people in need. Both shelters provide cool environments and showers, as well as hot meals, for those seeking refuge from the heat wave. Ash UssAdvocacy & Partnerships Cord. Andre House of Hospitality“In one of our more recent surveys, we found out that 50% of people that come here for dinner every night, leave here to go and sleep on the street.”We visited Andre House of Hospitality, and spoke to Ash Uss, media representative and Advocacy & Partnerships Coordinator.Ash UssAdvocacy & Partnerships Cord. Andre House of Hospitality“There are a lot of ways that the heat manifests, we see people being extremely irritable, with very short fuses, people who are normally so kind and patient, who are just exhausted by the heat.”“Unfortunately we have seen a fair share of people that we know and love, who have passed away, directly due to the heat.”Outside the shelter we met Joseph Johnson, a native american from the Phoenix rural area. He has been on the streets for more than 5 years and despite being accustomed to the heat, he let us know how much it still affects him every day.JosephHomeless, 50 years old“The effects are so very bad, the heat, some people are so exhausted, they want to get a shade, there is not enough shade around, yet they survive, they have to handle the heat with no shade, but we survive. But it does affect a lot … we have to go through these heat waves.”We spoke to Darlene, originally from Chicago; she came to Phoenix with a boyfriend that spent all of her money and then disappeared, leaving her desperately searching for him but also living on the streets.DarleneHomeless, 53 years old“It affects you a lot, I mean the heat exhaustion, you need to drink a lot of water … you have to make sure you get your supplies, it is hard work, it is a constant thing all day long, just to stay cool.It is important to get a shower, you know, keep your skin clean, and stay healthy, eat right, good food, you know … Andre House, we wouldn’t survive without this place out here, they give us our toiletries, our showers a place to stay cool during the day.I know that when I get back on my feet, I’ll get back here to help, because they really need it.”According to Darlene, heat fatalities deeply affect the morale of surviving homeless people. She said that the worst part for her, is to meet fellow homeless who had given up, because after that is almost impossible to help them survive.Ash UssAdvocacy & Partnerships Cord. Andre House of Hospitality“The average person does not know that there have been 20 people in this immediate area that have passed away from the heat. Simply because they were experiencing homelesness. Since July, July 1, so it has been a little over a month, that is 20 lives that are gone forever, you know, because of the heat.”DarleneHomeless, 53 years old“We get to have a lot of deaths this time of the year, I mean we had 6 in one weekend, from heat exhaustion, from [absence of] water, from dehydration. It is crazy, when there is so much water around us.So people, if they don’t deliver [water], I mean look across the street, there is handicap people, they can’t move around, so if they don’t get to medical services, they end up dying out here, we had a lot of young people, we had a 31 year old lady, who just died of heat exhaustion.”Joseph JohnsonHomeless, 50 years old“You try to sleep, you toss and turn, it is hot, but morning comes quick though, and it is still kind of hot in the morning, and it is going to be another hot day, and you know in your head it is going to be another hot day, and people know it and they realize what the next day it is going to be.”Beyond the tragedy of death, there is the tragedy of dehumanization. According to several sources, despite the fact that access to water is mandated by state law, homeless people are denied water all the time.DarleneHomeless, 53 years old“When you do go out in public, people tend to look at you like you are a contagious disease, carry a backpack and walk downtown for an evening, and people won’t give you service, they won’t give you water, by law they are supposed to in the state, but in restaurants, or in hotels, you know, they won’t give it to you, because you are homeless.”Stay with The Real News for more on the issue.
by Oscar León June 21, 2018 for TRNN
TTrump’s policy of separating immigrant children from their parents and holding them in cages is sparking a wave of public outrage
OSCAR LEON: The world is enraged, but the cages are not new. A once silent crisis, brewing for a decade, now is boiling.
Despite the more than 4 million immigrants deported by Obama, his successor faces a wave of refugees crossing the US-Mexican border to escape poverty and violence.
The steps that President Donald J. Trump and Attorney General Jeff Sessions have taken to address migration have enraged the country, the last of which broke on Thursday June 19 by AP. “Baby jails” were being set up to house unaccompanied minors of “tender age,” as they call them, in other words, immigrant babies.
The next day, the pressure was simply too much, and Donald Trump announced signing an executive order to stop the separation of families. But let’s look at the buildup that led to this moment.
The news had quickly spread around the world. The United States of America was separating children. Over the last month and a half, an estimate of 2000 minors who were unaccompanied have been put in detention centers, whether they had crossed illegally or had surrendered in ports of entry, in many cases in groups of people who were seeking asylum, escaping poverty and gang violence in Central America.
Even the U.N. called on the United States to stop separating families
RAVINA SHAMDASANI: There is nothing normal about detaining children. As I said, detention is never in the best interest of the child and always constitutes a child rights violation. On this being a criminal offense, as I said, this should, the, you know, entry into a country without the right papers, should at most be an administrative offence and it certainly does not warrant jailing children.
OSCAR LEON: Headlines like: “Children separated from their families crying in cages,” “The Bible is used to justify the separation of immigrant families in United States,” “Frightened children are being ripped from their parent’s arms and taken to overflowing detention centres, which are effectively cages.”
The reference by General Attorney Jeff Sessions to Saint Paul’s Romans 13 letter. in which he made a call to follow Roman law and avoid immigrating to the capital, ignited outrage in both Christian and Catholic communities, with many congregations of all kinds having meetings to discuss what to do, facing the horrible reality Erika Guevara-Rosas, Amnesty International’s Americas Director described as “Nothing short of torture. The severe mental suffering that officials have intentionally inflicted on these families for coercive purposes, means that these acts meet the definitions of torture under both US and international law.”
Children were separated from their parents and put in cages inside temporary detention centers awaiting its transfer to facilities like this former Walmart, in Brownsville, Texas. Their relatives will be sent to federal prisons like Eloy and Florence in Arizona. According to the Trump administration’s own words, there is no system in place to reunite these families.”
In Phoenix, Arizona, inclusive and progressive churches are working with grassroots organizations to spread awareness and raise their voices of disapproval.
REV. JAMES PENNINGTON: Personally, I kind of understand it as a fear of brown skin or black skin, anybody outside of white anglo. So to me i’s also an issue of race, it’s an issue of justice, it’s an issue of economics. It’s an issue of power, who has power, and who is really considered human and inhuman. This is our way to tell you to stop coming across our border, because we’re going to take your children.
OSCAR LEON: Rev. James Pennington is a Senior Minister at the The First Congregational United Church of Christ in Phoenix, Arizona; by all definitions, an inclusive church.
REV. JAMES PENNINGTON: We have received several individuals in sanctuary. And also, two years ago we started a immigration legal clinic, that was sponsored by and run by the church.
OSCAR LEON: This time the church had called for a town hall, where a panel of legal and social workers shared their expertise on the matter to an outraged public.
Patrick Helling, Managing Attorney for the Florence Project, an NGO that provides legal assistance to migrants, confirmed what had been reported. Children have been separated from their parents, and eventually placed in custody in facilities different than those of their relatives, who, according to the latest anti-immigrant laws, are not entitled to bail, and will remain incarcerated until they are deported.
More temporary detention facilities are being erected, like this tent city jail in Tornillo, Texas, designed for housing families and children until further processing and eventual transfer.
The immigrant kids that turn 18 and have not being reunified with a sponsor will be sent to general prison population. Carmen Smith-Estrada from The Florence Project confirmed this.
“There are a number of kids that arrive just before they turn 18 [who will] be transferred to detention centers for adults. If no one claims them, or they don’t qualify for a bond, or if they can’t pay the bond given to them, they will face a dire choice: sitting in jail until its case sorts itself out, or choose being [deported] back to their countries.”
The panel did notice that there is a way to help for those who are willing to. To join and support groups like The Phoenix Restoration Project and others. Doing hospitality work and claiming those minors before they are surrendered to the general prison system.
Jessica Brown, social worker with the Florence Project, who works with the actual children in detention, confirmed the severity of the trauma experienced by the caged children.
JESSICA BROWN: Not only the trauma experienced back home, but the trauma throughout their journey up to the U.S., and then arriving here and being ripped from their family, the protective care that has been with them, and then not knowing, really, what is going to happen.
OSCAR LEON: Through the two hours of the town hall meeting, people kept relating to the immigrant families and comparing the caged children to their own, even a group of mothers was formed to take direct peaceful actions in the matter.
VERONICA MONGE: I know that this has been happening for a long time, but seeing a lot of pictures in the news and the videos of the actual children has really inspired me to want to stop this, like right now.”
ERIN TAMAYO: As a mom I have a 2-year-old and a four-year-old, and they’re both of Latino descent. So every time I see the reports in the news of children being ripped away from their mothers, from their fathers, it just makes me so I can’t even sleep at night.
LEAH SARAT: One thing that we are facing with this issue of family separations is that is an acute form of state violence. And it is not a violence that leaves physical marks upon children, upon families, but the violence that is does to those attachment bonds, to the parent-child bond, can leave lasting, lasting traumatic effects upon these communities.
So I think that we are creating a problem that is going to have effects for generations to come. They are being placed in an institution at a very tender age. This reminds me of the institutionalization of Native Americans in boarding schools. Not very far past in our nation’s history. Does that mean that they’re going to be taught that their parents were, indeed, criminals?
OSCAR LEON: Speaking on Laura Ingraham’s show, General Attorney Jeff Sessions, or General Sessions, as she called him, struggled trying to explain the difference between today’s United States and 1940s Third Reich Germany.
Laura Ingraham: Nazi Germany, concentration camps, human rights violations. Laura Bush has weighed in, Michelle Obama has weighed in, Rosalynn Carter. You got all the first ladies going back to Eleanor Roosevelt. She’s apparently weighed in, as well. General Sessions, what’s going on here?
JEFF SESSIONS: Well, it’s a real exaggeration. Of course, in Nazi Germany they were keeping the Jews from leaving the country.
by Oscar León July 26, 2017 for TRNN
The Real News team spoke with first responders and science and medial experts in Arizona, where high temperatures have grounded planes and significantly increased health emergencies
OSCAR LEON: Record breaking temperatures have gripped Phoenix, Arizona. Why are you using gloves? JESS: To protect my hands from the heat, from basically the metal on the carts. OSCAR LEON: You burn yourself so far? JESS: When I don’t have them on, yes. OSCAR LEON: Right now, we have 109 degrees in Phoenix, Arizona, which is pretty hot, but this seems to normal here. However, last week, there were many days where records were broken. On Sunday, June 18, Phoenix reached 118 degrees with nearby Tucson hitting 115. Yuma, Arizona soared to 120 degrees. That’s the city’s fourth hottest day on record. On Tuesday, June 20, Phoenix record its fourth hottest day ever as well reaching 119 degrees. On June 21, officially the first day of the summer, it got so hot that planes were grounded. The forecast was 117 Fahrenheit and by 10:00 PM the temperature was reading 103 Fahrenheit. On social media, you can find pictures of people driving with oven mittens or trying to keep cool with ice packs in their cars. Dogs using shoes to walk in the pavement. Are these record highs a symptom of climate change? RANDALL CERVENY: High temperature records are being broken more frequently now than ever before, so that may be an indication that Earth is getting hot, become a hotter place. OSCAR LEON: Randall Cerveny is a President’s Professor at Arizona State University Geographical Sciences and Urban Planning School. He’s also the rapporteur on extreme records for the World Meteorological Organization. RANDALL CERVENY: With the increase of anthropogenic carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, one of the most common scenarios that we see in the models is that not so much the high temperatures are getting higher, although they are slightly, the bigger thing is that our low temperatures for the day are getting much higher. Back 20, 30 years ago in Phoenix, Arizona, we rarely had temperatures that were in the 90s for lows. Today, during the summertime, we’ll have several days where 90 degrees or higher is actually our low temperature for the day. OSCAR LEON: Last year between June 14 and July 14, 2016, Phoenix Fire Regional Call Center dispatch 279 assignments under the code of heat related illness. For the same 30 day period in 2017, Phoenix Call Center dispatch 977 assignments under the same code. That’s 498 calls than last year for the same time period. RANDALL CERVENY: The first sign for a heat stroke is heat exhaustion. That’s when you start feeling nauseous, maybe some vomiting, kind of dizzy, you get tired, some muscle cramps, real sweaty, and that’s heat exhaustion. That’s something we have to be conscious of and it’s important for people to realize that the temperatures here are much higher than where they’re probably from and they need to drink lots of water. That water needs to start 24 hours ahead of time. Drinking it as soon as you start feeling thirsty or tired, it’s too late at that point. It’s still important to drink at that point, but it’s too late to combat those signs of the heat exhaustion. It’s important to start drinking lots of water about 24 hours ahead of time. OSCAR LEON: Captain Axelrod from the Phoenix Fire Department warns that heat stroke can take over very fast often with progressive symptoms that could go unnoticed until it’s too late. BRIAN AXELROD: Heat exhaustion, if it’s not treated, if somebody doesn’t get water, doesn’t cool off, then it turns into heat stroke. Heat stroke is they’re no longer sweaty. They start to get real dry skin. Their skin starts to get real hot. They’re still nauseous. They’re maybe a little lethargic. Their heart rate will start to elevate. Their respiratory rate can also slow down and they can become unconscious. That’s a very serious life threatening emergency. OSCAR LEON: One of the hardest things to do to survive here in the heat in the sun in Arizona is when you leave your car in the sun, let’s say you’re working, you’re at school, whatever, you come out, open the door, wow, it’s like when you’re cooking and you open the door of the oven to see if your food is ready. Well, here in Phoenix, Arizona, your food is ready because this is extremely hot. In past weeks we have seen many examples of people cooking all kind of stuff in the cars. To understand the science behind this, I visit Arizona State University where I met Dr. Ariane Middel, a German scientist specializing in heat mitigation, who’s conducting very precise measuring temperatures at the ASU campus. ARIANE MIDDEL: This is a mean radiant temperature card. It measures how you experience air temperature in a hot dry desert like Phoenix. It has an air temperature humidity sensor. This is similar to a sensor you would find at the airport. It has a wind speed and direction sensor, a GPS so that we know the cart’s location, and then these are three pairs of net radiometers. Those measure the incoming and outgoing radiation, so it measures the radiation from the direct sunlight, that’s the short wave. It measures the long wave radiation, that’s the heat that’s emitted from surfaces that have been sun exposed. We measure this in all six directions. There are two front and back, two left and right, and then two up and down facing sensors, so that we get the radiation at 360 degree, basically all sides that hit a human body. OSCAR LEON: This card carries a system that the local scientists call [inaudible] because it measures radiant temperature. Ariane uses it to check reading in different parts of the campus and the city of Phoenix. Recording the findings to validate the accuracy of results by computer models that predict temperature. The goal is to develop an application that can [inaudible] you through hot humid environments. Not along the [inaudible] part, but along the most comfortable and shaded part. ARIANE MIDDEL: If the air temperature at the airport is 120 degrees Fahrenheit, mean radiant temperature can vary much, much more than the air temperature data from the airport. On a field work trip in June, on June 19, which was a record breaking heat day, I measured mean radiant temperatures of up to 75 degrees Celsius. RANDALL CERVENY: The big heat wave that took place at first part of this century in Europe killed hundreds of people, but the problem was that the infrastructure wasn’t built to handle it. They didn’t have air conditioning for most parts in places like France. In the late ’90s, there was a heat wave that centered itself over Chicago, Illinois, and over 500 people died within a two week period. It shows that heat waves in places that can’t handle the heat can be tremendously bad and given the fact that more high temperature records are being broken around the country and around the world, likelihood of having the potential for more heat waves increases. OSCAR LEON: What’s perhaps more alarming is that the Trump Administration is rolling back fossil fuel regulations and denies climate change is even real. For more of our coverage, visit TheRealNews.com
by Oscar León July 21, 2019 for TRNN
In contrast to the unwavering support that conservative and evangelical religious groups give President Trump, progressive churches and synagogues are fighting on the front lines against the administration’s anti-immigrant policies
NARRATOR: The United States’ religious right has been a hotbed of support for President Trump. Influential conservative mega church leaders have thrown their weight behind him. One is Paula White, a pastorwho runs a megachurch in Florida She claims to be on a divine mission, to help Trump hear “what God has to say”.In early 2018, 1000 theatres played a movie called “The Trump Prophecy,” which claims that Trump was chosen by God to restore America’s moral values, Others like Pastor Tom Horn have even called Trump the new incarnation of “The Messiah”.You can now attend churches that portray the president as a biblical figure or buy Bibles that mention him, including some painting him as a leader, heading a bible-like apocalyptic fight.The Manhattan billionaire has gained the unshakable favor of many mega churches and conservative institutions. He has done this mainly by advancing their agenda, from anti abortion laws, to a conservative supreme court, that could eventually favor them when key issues reach the highest authority. Also by routinely claiming that Christianity is under attack.The Trump administration has embraced the support of the religious right. According to The Christian Post, in August 27, 2018 the White House held a “state like” dinner for hundreds of Evangelical Leaders.DONALD TRUMP: As you know in recent years, the government tried to undermine religious freedom, but the attacks on communities of faith are over. We’ve ended it.The support you have given me has been incredible but I really don’t feel guilty because I have given you a lot back — just about everything I promised.NARRATOR: Vice President Mike Pence, a born again evangelical Christian, recently led a media tour through the detention camps and declared: “even the most hardened criminals in our criminal justice system are not treated like that, death row inmates don’t live in conditions like that.”Yet many pastors and spiritual leaders of the right, recently provided moral arguments to justify the separation of families and caging of children, such as pastor Robert Jeffress who openly praised Trump’s political action or Pastor Mike Jones who said that “Trump Putting Babies in Internment Camps is God’s Will – Or Fake News”RABBI DR SHMULY YANKLOWITZ: I think any religious institution, which diminishes suffering that is happening among the vulnerable populations, is living with religious hypocrisy.NARRATOR: This is Rabbi Dr. Shmuly Yanklowitz, an Open Orthodox rabbi, author and human rights defender.RABBI DR SHMULY YANKLOWITZ: They have abandoned their texts, because as someone who has studied various religions and have been exposed personally to them, I know that the core of every religion is compassion, it is mercy upon vulnerable people.And for [conservative religious groups] to say that they support the current administration, and policies that marginalize, and target the vulnerable, [they] are living with religious hypocrisy. No matter if they are Jews, Christian, Muslim, or have no faith at all.NARRATOR: But other religious organizations and leaders oppose the Trump administration. Even in evangelical organizations, some Trump-supporting pastors face disapproval from other members of their congregation One is David Platt, a pastor from a church in Virginia, who publicly apologize for praying with Trump, after the president paid him an unannounced visit.Last week hundreds of people took to the streets to oppose the administration’s harsh treatment of asylum seekers in detention centers. Here’s Father Andrew Barreras from the Reform Catholic Church.FR. ANDREW BARRERAS: Christ never talked against, he was for the immigrant. If we follow Christian values we should support them, help them, not mock them, not locking them up in cages, separate them, or abuse them, mentally, physically.NARRATOR: Some of the groups, working on the ground to relieve the suffering of ailing immigrants and asylum seekers, are religious organizations. OSCAR LEON: The activist group No More Deaths is a voluntary faith organization which is a ministry of the Unity Universalist Church of Tucson.NARRATOR: No More Deaths is a coalition of community and faith groups trying to stop immigrant deaths in the desert. For 15 years now, the group has worked at the border, providing humanitarian relief while risking detention and, as of late, persecution, by the Trump administration.Nine of the group’s activists have been detained and prosecuted in recent months, but they are not alone in their view. Many local groups form a network to support asylum seekers. These are small Latino and inclusive progressive churches, trying to reflect their interpretation of the gospel.FR JAMES PENNINGTON: Over the past four years we have been working pretty intently on immigration issues. And about two years ago we announced that we are a sanctuary church.NARRATOR: Father James Pennington leads the First Congregational United Church of Christ in Phoenix Arizona. They’re a member of United Church of Christ congregations, which according to their site has 5.000 churches and about a million members worldwide. Their progressive platform includes environmental issues, LGBTQ protections, minorities and immigrant rights, even sexual education.FR JAMES PENNINGTON: This issue of family values, and especially the current administration and administrations before that, which where talking about family values, that is not a family value.And then especially the statements that are heinous and say that -this is our way to tell you to stop coming to our country, we are going to take your children, and we are going to put them in some detention for children or Child Protective Services, that is just outrageous. And it is so anti anything that I understand as gospel and humanity.NARRATOR: First Church UCC, Phoenix provides shelter to undocumented immigrants who face deportation, and runs an immigration legal clinic.GORDON STREET: We are here to speak out against this moral injustice, going against the families and kids. It is not the right Christian thing to do. It is not the right human thing to do.NARRATOR: Commissioned Minister Gordon Street is an example of an “inclusive” new wave of faith.GORDON STREET: I think the more conservative right wing church forgets about,the basic human things that Jesus thought about. He hung out with people [like the] ones in here, speaking out against the establishment and what is human and right to do.NARRATOR: Father Pennington questions the values and consistency of conservatives religious groups.FR JAMES PENNINGTON: It is really hard to understand that kind of closed system of Christianity, which is a more conservative Christianity, which says we value families, and we don’t think we should abort a child. But once the child comes into the world, it’s like we don’t want to provide social services. We are going to pull them from their parents arms at the border.Like it is a total … it seems like to me, irrational. It is irrational.NARRATOR: Rabbi Yanklowitz thinks the time is now to exert change from within.RABBI DR SHMULY YANKLOWITZ: So we see in every religious group that binary happen, those who are resistant and pushing back against policies of hate, or those who are submitting to them because some archaic religious dogma. And each of us within our own religious camp have an obligation to speak up, and challenge people in our own religious communities, to realign themselves with our own ancient traditional values.NARRATOR: Father Pennington says to address these splits, there must be dialogue among both the left and right wings of the US’s religious communityFR JAMES PENNINGTON: And this is not just Christian, but it’s Muslim and it’s Jewish, and it is the three Abrahamic faiths that have this whole understanding of peace and equity and justice, and that we are all given the same rights as humans. Yet in each of those Abrahamic faiths we’ve had our times when we needed reformation, and we needed to be transformed and change our own narratives.So for me it has been really difficult to have those conversations. It is easier to have them with like-minded people, but we need to have them.NARRATOR: Stay with The Real News for more on the issue.
by Oscar León August 23, 2017 for TRNN
TRNN speaks to some of the thousands gathered to protest Donald Trump in Phoenix
Oscar Leon: Thousands of people gathered on Tuesday, August 22nd when President Donald Trump held his first rally after the violence in Charlottesville. Inside the Phoenix Convention Center speaking to thousands of his supporters, US President Donald Trump. Donald Trump: The media can attack me, but where I draw the line is when they attack you, which is what they do when they attack the decency of our supporters. Oscar Leon: Outside the convention center people also gathered, mostly to protest Donald Trump. Also among the anti-Trump crowd we saw some Trump supporters too, challenging the protestors. And militiamen armed with assault rifles, who refused to make any statements. These are some of the voices we heard. Genevieve Rice: I’m here to protest Trump. I’m not happy that he’s in our city and I hope that he doesn’t try to pardon Arpaio. Teresa: We can’t go back in time. Everybody deserves equality regardless, and if you aren’t standing against all of this fascist racism, then you’re for it. Michelle: I really think that having a peaceful protest to show how displeased we are and how we do not stand by Donald Trump’s rhetoric of racism, where he equates the KKK and white nationalists to other groups like ANTIFA and Black Lives Matter. Crowd: Our streets. Who’s streets? Our streets. Who’s streets? Our streets. Who’s streets? Our streets. Zaira Libier: We’re here to defend our people. Joe Arpaio terrorized our community for 24 years and Trump’s promise to pardon him is a slap in the face. It’s devastating to a lot of family members here in our community. Sabrina Buttler: The direction that they’re leading our country is fascist and obviously he doesn’t have a problem with fascism, the KKK, white supremacists, and it’s disgusting. And I’m here to stand with all these beautiful people that want to save our country from this disaster. Melissa: But I think for our country, the biggest issue right now, is the healthcare. He’s trying to take away all of our healthcare, and that’s not okay. Crowd: Black lives matter, black lives matter, black lives matter, black lives matter, black lives matter, black lives matter. Tash: I believe it’s very important for us to exercise our rights to assemble peacefully and to protest against the kind of bigotry, xenophobia, Islamophobia, hatred, intolerance, that Donald Trump stands for. Tasha: My name is Tasha [Burell] and I’m here because I have black children, point blank. Carmen: So I’m an immigrant. I am from Mexico and I have been in this continent longer than any white folks that have been here in this country, and I think that that’s one the issues, that this nation was built from immigrants from many different nations, not just one. So this country belongs to many people, not only white folks. Rashad: Yeah, I mean. You know the Trump administration, through its policies, through the rhetoric of the campaign, has really brought to the surface the worst aspects of American racism, and he has been explicitly involved. Hiring and working with Steve Bannon. Evoking age old racist stereotypes, and he has really brought neo-Nazi’s and white supremacists who hid in the dark regions of the internet, out into the public. And we saw that in Charlottesville. Oscar Leon: So these are some of the voices we heard outside the Phoenix Convention Center in what turned out to be an anti-Trump rally right outside a pro-Trump rally. Police stood in riot gear on Montrose Street between protestors and Trump supporters. As one group walked into the convention center, the two crowds had two barriers and the street between them. The protestors boo-ed the Trump supporters as they walked inside the convention center. Crowd: Shame on you. Shame on you. Shame on you. Shame on you. Shame on you. Ralph Buttler: I mean essentially those are Trump supporters man, and everyone’s just going ahead and letting them know that they’re not okay with, as she said, white supremacy, with the idea of a corporate America that shoves fascism down your throat, an obviously militarized police force that’s going to subjugate already oppressed peoples, and just the continued downward spiral of America. We’re all here to lift each other up. My grandpa didn’t fly halfway around the world to beat the Nazis so we could let them come back here and do this, dude. Crowd: Whose America? Our America. Whose America? Our America. Whose America? Our America. Whose America? Our America. Oscar Leon: Initially, as the rally first got underway, Phoenix police said there had been no arrests or significant incidents. This quickly changed and chaos erupted outside the Phoenix Convention Center. Police said in a statement to the press, that they were forced to deploy pepper balls and tear gas into the crowd because people were throwing rocks and bottles at them. The tear gas dispersed the crowd in the area. However, we contacted Reyna Montoya from Aliento, one of the organizers of the demonstration. She had a different version of what happened. “The march was completely peaceful. The violent ending was not expected. Apparently one woman threw a water bottle to a police officer. Without a warning or anything, I saw the tear gas. It started to burn my face, my eyes and I was coughing. I literally had to run from the gas. We are really disappointed at the Phoenix Police Department at how they tear gassed peaceful protestors without warning.” Puente. Another local NGO involved in the march also issued a statement. “After refusing to condemn white supremacists in Charlottesville last weekend, Trump came to Phoenix to rally them. He’s not too sure if Joe Arpaio is the latest sign of the white supremacy that is governing the white house.” And while Donald Trump so far has not pardoned former Sheriff, Joe Arpaio, inside the building the President of the United States blamed the media as the responsible for the climate of political division in the country. Donald Trump: But the very dishonest media, those people right up there with all the camera’s. These are truly dishonest people, and not all of them, not all of them. You have some very good reporters. You have some very fair journalists, but for the most part, honestly, these are really, really dishonest people. And just so you know from the Secret Service, there aren’t too many people outside protesting, okay. Oscar Leon: For the Real News from Phoenix, Arizona, this is Oscar Leon.
by Oscar León July 14, 2014 for TRNN
DREAM-ers in Arizona discuss the significance of the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals ruling that forces the southwestern state of Arizona to provide DACA recipients with driver licenses
OSCAR LEÓN, TRNN PRODUCER: On Monday, July 7, the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ordered the southwestern state of Arizona to provide with driver licenses to a group of undocumented immigrants brought to U.S. as children that fall under a special status created by President Obama two years ago.
Arizona Governor Janice Brewer said she will appeal the decision. She also directly blamed the current influx of minors and families over the Texan border on President Obama’s decision on June 15, 2012, to not deport minors who fell under certain qualifications and to grant them with a new special immigrant status known as DACA.
Some of the qualifications are:
In addition, every applicant must complete and pass a biographic and biometric background check.
The story of the lawsuit goes back to August 15, 2012, two months after President Obama signed the DACA memo.
In Arizona, Reyna Montoya and a group of activists had just applied for DACA and were ready to celebrate.
REYNA MONTOYA, AZ DREAM ACT COALITION: We were celebrating. We were so happy. We had a press conference in the morning at our office. And then, just hours later, Governor Brewer decides to do an executive action saying that she was going to deny drivers licenses specifically for the for-action applicants from childhood arrivals who are DACA recipients. So we were really mad.
CARLA CHAVARRIA, AZ D REAM ACT COALITION: We went to the capital and we decided to protest against this. But a couple of months after the ACLU, along with other organizations, decided to file a lawsuit, just calling it unconstitutional.
LEÓN: On May 2013, U.S. district judge David Campbell sided with Brewer against the plaintiffs’ argument of unconstitutionality. They then appealed, and the case eventually went to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.
MONTOYA: It has no rationale. If you look at the executive order from Governor Brewer, like, it’s very inconsistent and it doesn’t really have any reasons or any legitimate reasons for her. Why was she denied a driver’s license for someone who has work authorization to work here in United States? It makes no sense. And, actually, the Ninth Circuit decision said that it was something out of hatred, out of malice. That was the only reason that they could think why Governor Brewer was acting the way that she was.
LEÓN: And so, 23 months after the lawsuit was filed, the Ninth Circuit of Appeals ruled the governor’s ban unconstitutional.
Alessandra Soler, American Civil Liberties Union’s executive director, agrees with the court’s decision.
ALESSANDRA SOLER, ACLU EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR: Well, I mean, the governor definitely tried to, you know, rationalize what in our view was blatant discrimination. She made the decision based in not legitimate public interest or a legitimate public policy interest but on her, you know, politicking. And her decision was basically to pick a fight with the federal government, and these kids, these hardworking immigrants, were caught in the middle.
LEÓN: Governor Brewer reacted to the loss in court by issuing a statement:
“The ruling is especially disturbing given the current influx of illegal aliens, a crisis President Obama created and escalated. I am analyzing options for appealing the misguided court decision.”
She went on to say,
“If the Ninth Circuit ruling is allowed to stand, the president, as he has already threatened, can contrive a new program refusing to deport the latest arrivals, issue employment authorization cards, and Arizona would have to issue licenses to them as well.”
The governor went a step further and claimed,
“The DACA Program, the decision to not enforce federal law, has directly led to the massive influx of illegal crossings and the crisis we are witnessing today.”
Soler believes that the court saw through Brewer’s conjectures and political games and ruled they were violating the rights of the DACA recipients.
SOLER: And this was a huge, huge victory for these young immigrants. And it sends a really, really strong message to the governor that she cannot rationalize discrimination–and in this case, that’s exactly what the court found–and she can’t make decisions based off of spite and a hatred towards these young immigrants.
You know she claims that this has nothing to do with the dreamers, it’s about Obama, you know, ignoring the rule of law. Well, Brewer attacks everyone who disagrees with her as being lawless, and the court, the Ninth Circuit, saw trough this. And the Ninth Circuit said, you’re the one, in fact, that’s being lawless, you’re the one that’s violating the Constitution, and you’re the one that’s violating the rights of these young immigrants.
LEÓN: The core argument of the lawsuit is that only the federal government can enforce immigration laws, and that by trying to interfere with that process, Arizona’s governor was overstepping her lawful boundaries.
SOLER: There is a language in the U.S. Constitution that’s called the Supremacy Clause that says that the federal government is the entity that is expressly in charge of regulating immigration, and that states don’t have any business and don’t have any authority regulating immigration.
LEÓN: The Arizona governor’s main argument is that President Obama’s memo authorizing DACA is not equal to a Federal Law. This is a quote from her statement released after the loss in court:
“Arizona law, [A.R.S. § 28-3153(D),] is very clear: ‘Notwithstanding any other law, the department shall not issue to or renew a driver license or nonoperating identification license for a person who does not submit proof satisfactory to the department that the applicant’s presence in the United States is authorized under federal law.’ [emphasis Brewer’s] As a result, the Arizona Department of Transportation has a policy that DACA–as well as deferred action and deferred enforced departure individuals–do not demonstrate authorized presence under federal law.”
According to Soler, the judges’ ruling not only dismissed Brewer argument but reinforced the plaintiffs’ argument that states have no business regulating immigration law.
SOLER: They’re attempting to regulate immigration, and they don’t have the authority to do that. So one of the judges in this case actually said, hey, you’ve got a really good argument moving forward that her policy, not only does it discriminate against the DREAMers, but it possibly violates this Supremacy Clause by improperly interfering with the federal government’s ability to regulate immigration.
LEÓN: This is exactly the same argument used by the U.S. Supreme Court to rule out parts of the SB 1070, Governor Brewers’ first attempt to rule and regulate immigration in 2012.
But life is now about to change for these young Americans who only in Arizona and Nebraska had to endure for another two years the great inconvenience of living as subcitizens, not being able to drive in a place with a deficient public transportation system and temperatures up to 120 degrees Fahrenheit in the summer. This is just one of the problem they face day to day.
MAXIMA GUERRERO, AZ DREAM ACT COALITION: Me specifically, I wanted to go into the criminal justice field. I want to–I am studying criminal justice. And I wanted to go into law enforcement. And because I don’t have a driver’s license and I’m not a citizen, I can’t go join and protect my community that I’ve always wanted to protect since I was little. And I can’t go into the career that I want. I can’t–if there’s an emergency at the house and my younger siblings have an emergency, I wouldn’t be able to drive them somewhere. I wouldn’t be able to go to their games or their sports. It’s, like, little things like that, like returning something at the store and you don’t have a valid ID.
KORINA IRIBE, AZ DREAM ACT COALITION: It was kind of like a big shock when I started to grow up and started to see, like, Arizona in the political aspect of things and how I was being treated and how, you know, my family and our society as Latinos was being treated, because, like you said, growing up I had a lot of friends. I had white friends, black friends, you know, Mexican friends. And everything was great until, you know, as a DREAMer, when I started realizing all the obstacles of having to go to school and pay 300 percent tuition because of laws like Proposition 300, not being able to get scholarships, the anti-immigrant laws like SB 1070 here in Arizona, so anti-Latino. It was scary. And it was like, really, this is my home, this is where I grew up, and it’s really sad that now Arizona is turning its back on me.
~~~
CHAVARRIA: When I travel to other states and stuff, they’re always like, oh, you’re from Arizona? And they have that kind of, like, oh, kind of like–
OFF-CAMERA: I’m sorry.
CHAVARRIA: –I’m sorry for you, you know, kind of a feel.
~~~
MONTOYA, AZ DREAM ACT COALITION: I think there’s a lot of momentum, and I’ve seen how the community has really gotten active, not only being educated and creating awareness amongst our communities and really helping each other not only to grow[, go to education?], but protecting our families [as in stopping?] deportations. My dad deportation was stopped. And we here in the organization really try to really make it about our lives and really humanizing the issue that this is not about politics. But we do have Republicans who act out of hatred. But also we have Democrats who are not willing to take a stand for our communities and are not willing to protect them. So, for us it has never been about party but about our communities.
LEÓN: The Real News will continue to report about this case and other immigration issues. For The Real News, this is Oscar León.
by Oscar León June 15, 2014 for TRNN
As the harsh conditions faced by children in overcrowded immigration detention centers dominate headlines, The Real News looks at the policy that created these conditions
OSCAR LEÓN, TRNN PRODUCER: Over the last week, images showing hundreds of detainees have dominated the headlines across the country.
Right wing website Breitbart.com published images showing the dire conditions in which undocumented immigrants where being held before being transferred by bus to other facilities.
Law enforcement later acknowledged that about a thousand children where held in a warehouse in Nogales, AZ, which was being used as an [improvised] detention facility. The images of children sleeping on the floor, wrapped in shining emergency blankets, have circulated widely.
PETER BIDEGAIN III, SPOKESPERSON, U.S. CUSTOMS AND BORDER PROTECTION: The Border Patrol is making all the apprehensions. They had problems with bed space.
LEÓN: Peter Bidegain III, Customs and Border Protection’s spokesman, talked to us over the phone.
BIDEGAIN: We wait on–the office of refugee and resettlement, is the office that ultimately takes in unaccompanied minors that arrive at the U.S. So what’s happening is, as they lack bed space, we didn’t had the ability to transfer the unaccompanied minors out to them. So what’s happening is there’s a backlog in the processing of these individuals.
What we basically did is we started to transfer with DHS, Health and Human Services, and a couple of other agencies, we started to transfer unaccompanied minors from the Rio Grande Valley over to the Tucson sector to assist with processing.
LEÓN: Ray Ibarra is an experienced immigration attorney in Phoenix. He’s indignated about the response of authorities.
RAY IBARRA, IMMIGRATION ATTORNEY: Yeah, I mean, what’s happening right now on the U.S.-Mexico border is certainly a humanitarian crisis. Our immigration system should be set up to deal with situations like this, where people fleeing countries where their lives in danger. And we’d have better responses in putting people in small cramped rooms, lots of juveniles included, and really [inhumane] situations. To be busing them from one state to another state in the summer where it’s 110-plus degrees and not having food, water, or shelter available when those people get released is a complete injustice and not what the United States of America is supposed to be about.
LEÓN: So who are these kids and families detained in such conditions, overflowing Texas’s capacity to process? And why is there an overflow of detainees in the first place?
TONY BANEGAS, CONSUL OF HONDURAS FOR ARIZONA (SUBTITLED TRANSL.): When I got there last Saturday I met with 936 children in there, 236 from Honduras and the rest from Guatemala and El Salvador.
LEÓN: We spoke with Tony Banegas, Consul of Honduras for Arizona, who, along with the consuls of Guatemala and Nicaragua, are the only ones allowed to visit the minors.
BANEGAS: They are sleeping in plastic containers, covering themselves with aluminum blankets and using portable toilets. They are now installing showers; on Sunday they installed two, and they offered 60 more over the course of the week. So the kids can clean themselves, because many of them haven’t showered or changed their clothes for weeks now. They are awaiting toothbrushes and toothpaste, because they haven’t brushed their teeth in days.
LEÓN: Banegas says that the children, who were eating frozen burritos, are growing in number, and that in general the conditions they where detained where not good.
Parallel to the children transferred to the warehouse in Nogales, the news of hundreds of families released under parole on Greyhound stations, took first stage as well.
NEWS PRESENTER, FOX 10: Immigration offices can’t handle these cases. They’re being shipped here to Phoenix.
LEÓN: Here we are outside the Greyhound station in Phoenix, Arizona, where hundreds of immigrants have been dropped off as a transit point.
After being detained for immigration violations and processed by law enforcement, these families were being released under parole, and they were on their way to meet their relatives all over the country. Lacking space to hold them, Border Patrol gave the order to appear before immigration courts in 15 days and dropped them off at Greyhound stations in Phoenix and Tucson.
Republican governor Jan Brewer, known for passing SB 1070 in Arizona, criminalizing undocumented people, declared: “I am disturbed and outraged that President Obama’s administration continues to implement this dangerous and inhumane policy”. She urged president Obama to, quote, put a stop to the “dangerous and unconscionable” practice of shipping illegal immigrants out of Texas and dumping them in Arizona.
CINDY WHITMORE, THE RESTORATION PROJECT: I think there are a lot of politicians that maybe are really unfamiliar with what’s happening in their own backyard.
Cindy Whitmore from the Restoration Project in Phoenix, a nonprofit organization in Phoenix devoted to help these families:
WHITMORE: Everybody seemed very shocked that people were being released from ICE custody at the Greyhound. And it happens all the time. It doesn’t happen in those numbers, and certainly not with that many children at a time, but this happens all over the country, everywhere there’s a detention center; they’re transferred to the nearest Greyhound, and from there they are on their own.
LEÓN: The attention by the media have highlighted the conditions in which thousands of people are detained for immigration crimes.
WHITMORE: As we got to talk to these families and we learned about the conditions that they were being held in, we realized that they were being held for days and days, some reported as long as eight days, in a holding area that was really only designed for a few hours.
LEÓN: On June 12, The Washington Post published a leaked video showing women and children sleeping on concrete floors in 90 degree heat at the McAllen, Texas, Border Patrol processing center. We can see that the sick are separated of the rest by mere yellow tape. The room is evidently overcrowded. And we also see crying babies and expectant mothers. The newspaper reported that these detainees wait for days in such conditions, this after the turn themselves in. The report quotes:
“Every day, hundreds of Central American migrants, in groups as large as 250 people, are wading across the muddy Rio Grande and turning themselves in to the Border Patrol as helicopters and speedboats with mounted machine guns patrol the river.”
Michelle Brané, director of Migrant Rights and Justice Program of the Women’s Refugee Commission, thinks many of the families and people crossing the border should qualify as refugees.
MICHELLE BRANÉ, DIRECTOR, MIGRANT RIGHTS AND JUSTICE PROGRAM, WOMEN’S REFUGEE COMMISSION: A lot of these children are violence refugees. They’re fleeing violence. They’re fleeing a situation on which their lives are at risk. They’re being persecuted I think, really. And the governments of the countries they live in are unable to protect them.
LEÓN: The main problem for Border Patrol and Customs Border Protection is that many of these immigrants are not for Mexico but from Central America and they cannot be simply dropped off on the Mexican side of the border.
Peter Bidegain III confirmed that there is an increase of migrants from Central America apprehended at the border.
BIDEGAIN: Well, the majority of the unaccompanied minors that we’re seeing are from Central America. So they’re from El Salvador, Honduras, and Guatemala.
LEÓN: The Real News have reported about these issues for years now. Back in 2013 in one of our stories, Gene Valee, a founder of No More Deaths, had told us that now the majority of immigrants are from Central America, not Mexico.
GENE VALEE, FOUNDER NO MORE DEATHS: These are the things that have changed: there are certainly fewer Mexican people coming into the United States, and there are more people from Honduras, where there’s been a lot of violence in the last couple of years. And there’s still a continuing large number of people from Guatemala who are coming in for the same reason.
LEÓN: The University of Arizona found that “economic conditions in Central America, coupled with increasing violence there, is pushing more Central Americans to migrate north”.
VALEE: What’s been happening is that the percentage of people dying has gone up in the last two or three years.
SILKY SHAH, INTERIM EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF DETENTION WATCH: There are probably about 34,000 people detained at any given time in detention centers around the country, and the conditions are fairly bad.
LEÓN: Silky Shah from Detention Watch Network argues that the immigrants’ detainees rights are routinely violated by law enforcement.
SHAH: So ever the course of fiscal year 2012 we saw 478,000 people be detained over the course of the year. That’s an all time high. It’s been higher than ever before under the Obama administration. And we currently actually have a quota system that requires at minimum 34,000 people being detained. And this quota system is in place in appropriations, so it’s a part of how Congress funds Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
LEÓN: Beyond the fact that by law there have to be 34,000 people detained, Shah also argues that the U.S. is prioritizing law enforcement while not providing the detainees with adequate care.
SHAH: The majority of facilities that are used are outsourced. ICE, Immigration Customs Enforcement, has no real mechanisms for oversight. So some of the conditions that we’ve heard about are people, you know, not getting the medical or mental health care that they need. A lot of times people are inside detention for 23 hours a day, don’t even get to go outside. Sometimes it’s just a window in a room that makes it seem like they’re, you know, getting some outside air, but they’re not actually getting to go outside. There’s a lot of use of solitary confinement. A lot of complaints about the food, really terrible food, people not getting enough food a lot of times, and so they have to spend money at the commissary, which is very expensive.
A lot of the times what happens with detention is that the priority is to make money in some way, whether it’s for profit or for your county, as opposed to care.
LEÓN: The American Civil Liberties Union (the ACLU) and the National Prison Project released a study called Warehoused and Forgotten. The report quotes:
“Nationwide, more than half of all federal criminal prosecutions initiated in fiscal year 2013 were for unlawfully crossing the border into the United States–an act that has traditionally been treated as a civil offense resulting in deportation, rather than as a criminal act resulting in incarceration in a federal prison. This is dramatically changing who enters the federal prison system.”
The tipping point came in 2009, when more people entered federal prison for immigration offenses than for violent, weapons, and property offenses combined–and the number has continued to rise each year since.
Precisely the ACLU and a coalition that includes the National Immigrant Justice Center filed a lawsuit against CBP (Customs and Border Protection) for widespread abuse of children. The coalition represents over 100 unaccompanied children mistreated by Border Patrol Agents after being apprehended at the border.
Michelle Brané says that there is no unified database to locate people detained at the border.
BRANÉ: One thing that we’ve been trying to get Border Patrol to do or DHS to do at the border for many years now it to create a sort of locator system. In this case, they would only have to make a contact to say, yes, your child is here and they are okay, or they’re going to be transferred to this location.
LEÓN: According to Peter Bidegain III, Customs and Border Protection’s spokesman, the best chance to find a relative or a child missing while crossing the border is precisely to contact the consulate office of their countries of origin.
BIDEGAIN: Yeah, so if the family’s already here in the United States and they have a relative that they think is in, you know, Border Patrol custody or Office of Refugee Resettlement or any other government agencies, what the family needs to do is reach out to the consulate of their country.
LEÓN: Tony Banegas, Consul of Honduras for Arizona, say the number of children detained in the warehouse keeps growing.
BANEGAS: They are more than 1,000 by now. A lot of people have been calling me to try to find out about a missing relative or children. They are calling from all around the U.S. and even Honduras, knowing the children are on U.S. soil. The relatives are anxious, but I can’t tell them when the children are going out of detention; it all depends to U.S. authorities. I have names and information about all of the children I interviewed. I have information about their parents and places of origin, even their phone numbers.
But at the time, I am too busy. I don’t have time [to call them] or process any of that. I am doing what I can. I have so many phone calls that I can’t answer to all of them. And at the time, it’s only me here [in the consulate]. Right now I was running out the door towards Nogales.
LEÓN: Silky Shah argues that the images of crowded jails are no more than the tip of the iceberg, showing the face of thousands of human beings whom trying to escape economic devastation ended up trapped in private jails for profit.
SHAH: The problem is less that, you know, there’s overcrowding; the problem is that there’s over-incarceration and over-detention. There’s a mass detention system that doesn’t need to exist. The only reason anybody is in detention is because they’re showing up to–they need to show up to a hearing to determine their status.
LEÓN: According to the department of Health and Human Services, on fiscal year 2013, Border Patrol apprehended 24,668 unaccompanied minors. The numbers for 2014 are expected to rise at around 60,000.
On June 2, President Obama declared the U.S.-Mexico border under an “urgent humanitarian situation”, acknowledging the grave conditions of the minors. This declaration is expected to release $1.4 billion for border agencies under the control of Federal Emergency Management Administration (FEMA). According to federal officials, this declaration will provide the shelters with medical treatment, food, and mental health services.
With poverty rates and gang-related violence growing in Central America, it is reasonable to wonder how much more money and manpower will be needed to control this new wave of central American refugees, which adds to the already thousands of people trying to cross the border that separates the First World and the Third World.
Reporting for The Real News, this is Oscar León.
by Oscar León April 7, 2014 for TRNN
From the Mexico border to Washington DC, a group of families and activists fight to reunite Jaime Vasquez and Ardani Rosales with their families; these two fathers represent more than 2 million people deported over the last 5 years. The actions call on President Obama to stop deportations.
OSCAR LEÓN, TRNN PRODUCER: The fight for the immigration reform, and especially to stop the separation of families by immigration enforcement in the United States, is at a crucial point. While the immigration reform law is immobilized in Congress by intense political pressure, the deportations continue.
Activist and human rights organizations’ campaigns continue to gather support for immigration reform and to exert pressure over authorities to stop certain deportations and to even reunite some families.
Even in Rome, Buzzfeed reported that heeding the petition by Jersey Vargas, a 10-year-old girl, from Los Angeles, Pope Francis asked President Barack Obama, who visited him in the Vatican, to intercede for the little girl’s father and stop his deportation process.
This strategy apparently worked, as Mario Vargas was released the next day from a jail in Louisiana. Vargas had a clean profile, a U.S. native son, a daughter who qualifies under the DREAM Act, and the help of pro bono attorney Alex Galvez.
In that context, a week of action took place, first in Arizona and eventually nationwide.
On Tuesday, April 1, a group of activists and families traveled to the border entry of Nogales to support the return of Jaime Valdez and Ardani Rosales, two parents who, according to their families, had been deported by ICE as a retaliation, in the context of many weeks of direct actions, when the family, supported by activist, was protesting outside Immigration and Customs office in Phoenix.
LEÓN: According to these families turned activists on February 26, 2014, Phoenix Police raided them while fasting outside the ICE office. At the same time, ICE deported Jaime Valdez, accusing him of inciting other detainees to join the hunger strike, as Jaime told his father once deported. He had spent three months in Joe Arpaio’s Tent City before serving another eight months in the notorious conditions of Eloy for-profit prison.
JAIME VALDEZ, RETURNING DEPORTEE: I’m here in Nogales in this community center. [SUBTITLED TRANSL.] and I want to go back (to U.S.), because I love my family.
LEÓN: For Ardani Rosales’s family it was very hard as well. His wife gave birth while he was in jail for one year and nine months, before being deported while his family protested outside the detention center.
NAIRA ZAPATA, WIFE OF ARDANI ROSALES (SUBTITLED TRANSL.): My husband Ardani was detained when I was two months pregnant with my daughter. Now she’s eight months. He was deported when we were in front of ICE, praying for them to let him go. Sadly, they took him out the back entrance so we wouldn’t see him, and he was deported.
LEÓN: Now the activists of Puente Arizona are promoting an active campaign to ask Immigration and Customs Enforcement to re-open their immigration cases. For that purpose, on Tuesday, April 1, at 11 a.m. Jaime presented himself at the Mexican side of the border in Nogales.
ACTIVISTS: Bring Jaime home!
JAIME VALDEZ, RETURNING DEPORTEE: Today we’re going to try to get into the U.S. by the port of Nogales.
LEÓN: A group of activists and families gathered outside the border control office to show support. He was detained upon entering U.S.
Jose Valdez, Jaime’s father, watched from Puente offices in Phoenix as his son entered the offices accompanied by his lawyer.
That day, Ardani Rosales failed to appear in the Nogales Gate. His son Pablito was waiting for him, accompanied by Puente activists. Naira, Ardani’s wife, was not able to risk a trip to the border.
On Wednesday, April 2, Ardani arrived to Nogales, and after so many months away, on the Mexican side of the border he was able to spend some time with his son Pablito before surrendering himself on the U.S. border in Nogales.
To support them, a group of activists initiated parallel direct actions. A march of members of Puente and families of deportees initiated a 70 mile walk from Phoenix to Eloy detention centers. They walked for three days and camped outside the for-profit prisons.
CARLOS PUENTE, EXEC. DIR., PUENTE: So right now we’re outside the Eloy Detention Center after a three-day 60 mile march from the Phoenix ICE offices. Right now we’re setting up camp, ’cause we’re going to be sleeping here, having a vigil outside the detention center. And tomorrow we’ll be having a rally outside the Eloy detention center, asking to stop the deportations and [allow] the release of our family members.
LEÓN: Other group of activist and families initiated an even longer trip to the capital of the country, in an effort they identified under the hashtag #AZ2DC. Since Thursday, they demonstrated outside the White House and in many other parts of Washington, District of Columbia. Many more people joined over the weekend, reaching out to President Obama to ask for an end to deportations and separations of family.
On Saturday, the protest to support this effort reached many cities, including Phoenix, Des Moines, Los Angeles, and Washington, D.C. Huffington Post reported actions planned in more than 50 cities across the United States.
CESAR VARGAS, DIRECTOR, DREAM ACTION COALITION: So we are seeing a great strength of coming out from people who are being affected. Well, there’s a lot of leadership encouraged because people are no longer afraid. So that has been an extraordinary development of really the community coming out and saying, enough is enough, Mr. President, we need to story this, the crisis.
LEÓN: The New York Times in a Sunday editorial speaking about the president, the editorial board, summed it up this way:
“All Mr. Obama has been saying lately is: No, in fact, we can’t, because Republicans and the law won’t let me.”
After noting that while making promises to the immigrant community Obama has ramped up the enforcement, with over 2 million deportees in the last five years and more than 5,000 children ending in foster care, the editorial board of New York Times called the president up this way:
“The administration should abandon quota-based enforcement driven by the urge to fill more than 30,000 detention beds every day. And it should require bond hearings before immigration judges for people who have been held longer than six months, and end solitary confinement and other abusive conditions for detainees. Above all, it should direct the nation’s vast immigration enforcement resources more forcefully against gangs, guns, violent criminals and other genuine threats.
“These and other reforms should not be confused with a comprehensive overhaul of immigration, which only Congress can achieve. But they are ways to push a failing system toward sanity and justice.”
Back in Arizona, Jaime and Ardani are in prison waiting and wishing to go back to their families and their lives. His lawyer explains the case.
RAY A. YBARRA MALDONADO, LAWYER REPRESENTING JAIME VALDEZ AND ARDANI ROSALES: So Ardani and Jaime’s cases are extremely weak. These are cases of two individuals who have already been ordered deported, they’ve had their day in front of an immigration judge, and immigration said, denied, removed to your country of origin.
Despite them being deported, they decided to come back into the country. We presented a petition for humanitarian parole to allow them back into the country.
They’re now detained in Florence, Arizona. What I’ve been told by the deportation officer: waiting for a day with the immigration judge, which is great for both of their cases. But it is something different that we haven’t really seen before, of people trying to come back after already very shortly being deported.
LEÓN: Jaime and Ardani now face a complex legal battle before being able to go back to their home and his family. However, in this battle, now they have the backup of a community of activist and families supporting the fight for Not One More deportation.
Outside the White House, the activists remain demonstrating and claim they wont leave until president Obama hears their petitions and frees Jaime Valdez and Ardani Rosales.
Reporting for The Real News, this is Oscar León.
by Oscar Leon August 24, 2012 for TRNN
by Oscar Leon December 30, 2013 for TRNN
140 people died crossing the US-Mexico border in 2013
OSCAR LEÓN, TRNN PRODUCER: In 2013, Immigration and Customs Enforcement reported a total of 369,000 removals of “illegal aliens”. A large part of that total, 235,000, were deportations of individuals detained while trying to enter the U.S. border. If you compare that number to the 590,000 detained on 2004, it is clear that less people tries to enter the south border illegally.
At the same time, in the fall, The Arizona Daily Star reported 140 deaths in the border, a number that according to ICE has remained steady over the last decade, meaning more died on proportion trying to cross the desert.
This is an undocumented immigrant describing the dangers of crossing the border.
UNNAMED “ILLEGAL ALIEN” (SUBTITLED TRANSL.): It took, like, 18 hours of a real battle against the heat and then the cold. And then … God bless we made it here [inside U.S.] I was very tired and I began to doubt it … They tell you that “we are about to get there”, and it’s not true–they’re still a long way. Water runs out and … you know, you get scared of getting lost, or who knows what else can happen. As there is no more water and you are so tired, you start to fail and to think about surrender if they find you. It feels ugly … imagine how difficult it is for women. Crossing the desert is a struggle. The steps feel eternal. Walking is hard, and you are tired. It feels like you are not progressing anymore.
LEÓN: The guards apprehended six people out of the group we just saw on the thermal camera. Here they come.
~~~
GROUP OF DETAINED IMMIGRANTS (SUBTITLED TRANSL.): We are really sad and tired now. Also, look at the thorns. There are so many thorns.
LEÓN (SUBTITLED TRANSL.): Hard trip?
UNNAMED: We will never surrender. Never!
LEÓN: Do you think they can stop you with fences and walls?
UNNAMED: No, never! Where else can we get a decent house, a car, a job? We all just want to improve our lives. It is the governments’ fault. There is money here [in the U.S.] That is why we keep coming.
~~~
LEÓN: No More Deaths is an organization that works to “end death and suffering on the U.S./Mexico border”. Since 2004 they have provided water and emergency supplies to those in need.
GENE VALEE, FOUNDER NO MORE DEATHS: What’s been happening is that the percentage of people dying has gone up in the last two or three years, more than what it was before. There are more people dying per thousand coming across because of those factors. One of them is more people are arriving at the border without the money to hire guides to make the trip, trying it on their own. And secondly, they are going–they’re being pushed more by law enforcement into the mountains. These are the things that have changed.
There are certainly fewer Mexican people coming into the United States, and there are more people from Honduras, where there has been a lot of violence in the last couple of years. And there’s still a continuing large number of people from Guatemala who are coming in for the same reason.
LEÓN: The University of Arizona found that “economic conditions in Central America, coupled with increasing violence there, is pushing more Central Americans to migrate north”.
VALEE: In the last couple of years, we’ve seen a great increase in the number of people who were picked up inland United States by ICE and taken to the border and dropped. And those people often have family that are United States citizens, their children or maybe their spouses. And they’re picked up on a traffic violation, and within a couple of days they’re dropped at the border, on the other side of the border.
And they have no resources. So they come without money. They come without contacts. Many don’t have any contacts in Mexico because it’s been 20 years or so since they were there. And they’re left without resources. So there’s been a tremendous need. And these people are often turning right around and trying to come back into the United States.
LEÓN: Back in the summer of 2010, The Real News spoke to agent Norman Dotti, public relations attaché from Tucson’s Boder Patrol, who on a ride-along patrolling the border, at 105 Fahrenheit degrees, explained the effects of excessive heat.
~~~
NORMAN DOTTI, BORDER PATROL AGENT: Yes, a gallon per hour, especially in this environment, a gallon per hour when you’re walking in this heat and you’re sweating profusely. And then, once you run out of water, actually, from sweating and you can’t cool off anymore, and then the body starts to take–serious problems are happening with the body. And, again, they bring these water bottles that are just not enough for the journey they’re going to be taking. And if they’re not hydrated before they start this journey, the odds for them becoming very dehydrated is increased.
LEÓN: But you dehydrate even under a shadow in the desert?
DOTTI: Yeah, yes, you do. If you–once you start losing fluids by sweating and trying to cool yourself down to counteract the heat in the environment, once you run out it starts snowballing and you start becoming–the body starts shutting down ’cause it can’t handle that temperature. And even though you’re in the shade, that helps just a little bit. It helps to take some of the heat off.
But you’re still in the environment and the heat is still there. The heat hasn’t gone away. I’ve seen it get 110 here. I’ve seen it get–I’ve been out here when it’s been 112, 115. I don’t know what the top, the peak temperature would be or what time of year the peak temperature would be, but it does get very hot out here.
~~~
VALEE: In the same area, in the same place, really, that some of the people were coming from the south in the 1980s, it’s been happening in recent years. So some of us that were out there then came back together and said, what are we going to do? And we decided, well, we’ve got to get water into the desert. These people are dying. That’s number one.
And from that, three organizations developed. Humane Borders, which puts water tanks in the desert, has about 80 water tanks along the border, and people can go to those. They see a blue flag, and they go over and have water. And a second group, called Samaritans, that are people that go out of Tucson and Green Valley, and they take along a medical person and a Spanish speaker, and they look for people in trouble, and they give them food and first aid and water and help that way. And then we started No More Deaths, because people were still dying. And No More Deaths stays in the desert.
LEÓN: These are the tanks full of water in the desert, and these are distress signals for those who will need it and are lucky enough to make it here. The desert is full of many dangers. According to Dotti, not only all kinds of thorns, but also sudden holes and gullies are known to cause major harm, and sometimes death, to those who break legs or even hurt ankles.
DOTTI: You would need some help if you were to fall here and injure your leg or hit your head on a rock.
LEÓN: After apprehending a group of people crossing the border, the agents search through their things and try to get as much information as they can. Dotti sends them away. And then he finds another track, possibly another individual or group. However, these tracks seem to be more confused and out of purpose.
I followed the agent, and we found a man badly dehydrated. He asked me to encourage him to drink water, since the man is scared of his uniform, and I quickly talked to him in Spanish.
The man is agonizing, coming in and out of consciousness. Agent Dotti wouldn’t let me film at first, but after I managed to make the man drink water, he allowed me to take these images of the man talking to Esmeralda Marroquin, a border patrol agent from Mexican descent that arrived shortly after.
~~~
ESMERALDA MARROQUIN, BORDER PATROL AGENT (SUBTITLED TRANSL.): You are going to be okay.
MAN (SUBTITLED TRANSL.): Just now… we just wanted to… We were just trying … we … we were … just a bit more … And he is dead now. He is dead. My cousin is dead!
MARROQUIN (ENGLISH): Somebody’s out there dead. Somebody died.
MAN: It is too sunny.
~~~
LEÓN: I later found out from border patrol that the man had survived and had been deported back to Mexico after a period in jail.
Reporting for The Real News this is Oscar León.
by Oscar Leon January 21, 2014 for TRNN
Despite nationwide mobilization, immigrant advocates acknowledge they have failed to reform a broken immigration system
OSCAR LEÓN, TRNN PRODUCER: In 2013, Immigration Customs Enforcement, or ICE, an agency of the Department of Homeland Security, deported around 369,000 people from U.S., out of which 134,000 were apprehended inside the country. Many of them are detained by ICE raiding in their houses or picking them up at work. Over the last few years, hundreds of thousands of families have been separated by immigration policies.
For example, according to USA Today, if we count prosecution of illegal entry and re-entry cases, “there has been a 367 percent increase from a decade ago and a 1,420 percent increase from two decades ago”. By the end of 2013, the Obama administration had reportedly deported close to 1.9 million people, according to Homeland Security’s own numbers.
The Real News spoke to several undocumented workers.
UNDOCUMENTED WOMAN 1: I have no papers. I have worked in hotels since I got here [to the U.S.] 11 years ago.
UNDOCUMENTED WOMAN 2: Since I have no legal papers, I get scared. I am not from U.S., and these days you can get detained driving in the street and get deported, lose it all.
LEÓN: To get a legal work visa for U.S., it is required a set of skills in concept unmatched by local people, as well as an employer who will take full responsibility for the applicant, setting this possibility away from the majority of would-be undocumented immigrants, many of whom were brought here as a child.
UNDOCUMENTED CHILD: I feel bad that they can detain my dad. And [during the day] I miss him. In school I have American and Mexican friends alike, and we all play football and baseball just the same.
LEÓN: But this clampdown on illegal immigration is not only a federal effort. Many states have passed legislation to control illegal immigration. In 2007, Arizona passed a groundbreaking law targeting employers hiring illegal immigrants. Raids ensued in 2008, creating a climate of fear among many Latino communities in Arizona. Fearing deportation and racial profiling, life fundamentally changed for thousands of families.
Massive demonstrations in the summer of 2008, and an injunction in a federal court eventually scaled down the reach of the original laws, including the propositions to turn not only cops but hospitals and schools into immigration controls.
LEÓN: Erika Andiola is an immigrants rights activist, winner of the 2013 Freedom From Fear Award. Her life changed in 2008 when her Arizona State University scholarship was canceled after the state passed Proposition 300, banning students who cannot prove to be legal residents from receiving financial assistance from the State.
Smart and outspoken, Erika quickly became an icon of the Immigration Rights movement in Arizona, fighting criminalization of undocumented people. She graduated from ASU (Arizona State University) and eventually got a job as staffer for Democratic Senator Kyrsten Sinema.
But she recently left that job in D.C. to come back to Arizona and fight her mother’s deportation. On Thursday, December 12, 2013, Andiola announced her mother will be allowed to remain in the U.S. for another year.
ERIKA ANDIOLA, DREAM ACTIVIST: You know, they took her and my brother, and it was just sort of like a wake-up call. Like, you know, if I’m going to go in there, I’m going to need to make something happen so that at the end of the year we can have a legislation that is going to prevent my mom from actually being deported.
But, unfortunately, when I went in there, I saw that there’s too many games being played inside by both parties, that it’s not necessarily now about, you know, the anti-immigrant Republicans holding everything. It’s also about both leaderships in the House of Representatives that are, you know, seeing this issue as something that they can win for their own party. And that’s how I made the decision. And I want to be able to actually speak my mind about what I saw in there.
And I didn’t like also seeing a lot of the Democrats that were actually, like, you know, thinking about this issue in a way that they can get more votes in 2014, you know, by not passing something, and some of the Republicans in the leadership that are scared of their own party and they don’t want to do anything about it. So it’s sort of we’re trapped into this game. And I feel like I’m more–you know, I can actually fight better with my community outside.
LEÓN: Randy Parraz, a local community organizer and progressive activist, believes that the diverse Latino, pro-human rights, and pro-immigrant rights coalitions failed at their purpose to push for immigration reform in 2013.
RANDY PARRAZ, COMMUNITY ORGANIZER: Ultimately the goal was immigration reform in 2013. It didn’t happen, so it is a failure. A lot of people don’t want to say that. They want to say, oh, we’re closer. But who knows if we’re closer, ’cause once we get in 2014, states start having primaries and not many folks are going to be focused on a landmark piece of legislation like immigration reform going into an election year. So does that mean 2015?
So I think for the most part we have to come to the realization that the strategies we deployed, the power that we built were not enough to make it happen in 2013.
I think right now the Republicans are in a difficult situation because if immigration reform was to pass right now, they would get very little credit for it. It’d be mostly the Democrats. And if it includes a right to vote, a pathway to citizenship, Republicans will see that’s giving another 8-10 million more people who are going to vote for the Democratic Party.
LEÓN: According to ICE, in 2012, 45 percent of the deportees have no criminal record. That is almost 185,000 people. And in 2013, that number went down to 18 percent which represents 24,000 people. This means that over the last couple years, around 210,000 individuals who had not committed any kind of criminal offense have been taken out of United States and, in many cases, away from their families, with all the grave implications this carries.
From “24-hour notice” letters demanding the person to be present at the airport the next day and leave the country voluntarily to midnight raids, the lives of millions are touched by the fear of that moment when they will lose all that they have fought so hard to get.
For the Andiola family, the dreaded moment came in the middle of the night, when immigration agents broke down the doors and stormed in their home just a few days after her mom had been stopped while driving.
ANDIOLA: I knew it could happen, and it had happened before I was involved. You know, my mom was raided before at work by Sheriff Arpaio. And so there was always, you know, the fear that something could happen.
I feel the surprise came more out of the fact that I was so outspoken that I never thought that they would target my family, I guess. But the reality is that, you know, it could happen to anyone. And it happened to her. You know, she got stopped out of nowhere, literally, supposedly for speeding. She didn’t even get a ticket. But she did get sent to the police to take her fingerprints. And, you know, next thing you know, ICE is already at our house. And this happens every day–in Arizona, in Maricopa County, happens even more.
LEÓN: However, in Arizona, a social movement was born as a reaction to such anti-immigrant laws. Back in 2008, just a year after the passing of SB 1070 “the broadest and strictest anti-illegal immigration measure in recent U.S. history”, as The New York Times called it, the movement successfully recalled Russell Pierce, the main promoter of such controversial legislation.
Randy Parraz was one of the main organizers of the successful recall effort.
PARRAZ: Yeah, I think there’s been tremendous change. I think finally people have started to come together and fight back and to get some real victories.
Like, the first for us, even in the darkest of times, when, you know, Jan Brewer became governor, SB 1070 was passed by, pushed by Russell Pearce, within a year of that time, you know, we had a campaign to recall Russell Pearce and remove him from office, which was unheard of and unprecedented. So I think that was huge move forward in a different direction for Arizona.
And now we just have to build on those victories. We’ve got to keep holding people like Sheriff Arpaio and Governor Brewer accountable as we move forward.
So I think that, by removing Russell Pearce as president of the Senate has definitely set a different tone, where some of these anti-immigration bills are no longer being heard. By not taking out Russell Pearce, he would have been president. That Medicaid expansion never would have happened in this state. He would have, you know, really clamped down with the Tea Party in the Senate and really shut that down. So I think that’s tens of thousands of people getting Medicare coverage that would not otherwise.
So I think we’re moving in a better direction. But the challenges are still here, and I think there’s still opportunity and promise, but it’s not going to happen just because we want it to.
LEÓN: Erika is one of many activists who believe that the main obstacle for immigration reform is the prison-industrial complex.
ANDIOLA: Yeah. I mean, it’s an issue that is sort of like a taboo for many people, especially in D.C. because there is a lot of money being spent by these corporations.
But it’s a huge issue. And the way I see it is that it’s a human issue, right? You cannot expect to have, you know, these really big prisons just–they don’t call them prisons. They call them detention centers. But for us they’re prisons, right? You can’t expect to have all these, you know, places to hold people and not commit human violations. You have tons of undocumented folks who are being stopped for literally, you know, driving without a license, and they end up in those places for about a year. And so, you know, having those being a for-profit, I guess, for-profit place or a detention center, then it causes for a lot of, you know, legislators to actually not want to get the problem fixed as much as they should.
LEÓN: The prison-industrial complex is a name used to describe a private industry that Huffington post reported to have contributed as much as $45 million on a small army of lobbyists to successfully entrench itself on both sides of the aisle on Capitol Hill. In 2012, an Associated Press report found that the Federal Bureau of Prisons is paying $5.1 billion to private prison corporations for immigration detention through several year-long contracts.
Andiola denounces the conditions in for-profit detention centers close to Phoenix, like Eloy and Florence, which are but small local components of the nationwide private prison industry.
ANDIOLA: My mom went through Eloy–not Eloy. Florence. And she all of that, right? She saw–you know, she was actually chained herself. They chained her arms to her legs for no reason. She had no criminal background. She’s a 55-year-old woman. It makes no sense for them to do that. And they do it to her, to women, to people who are–you know, women who are pregnant, and men who have committed no crime in the past.
LEÓN: Parraz believes that beyond the powerful prison-industrial complex’s lobby, it is in the people’s hands to fight for their rights.
PARRAZ: Yeah. I think it’s more than a shortage of financial resources. I think it’s a short of courage and people willing to take the risk and sacrifice to make things happen. Right now on the Capitol lawn there are people fasting for immigration reform, but the problem is they’re in one tent, in a small tent. If there are indeed 11 million people who are suffering, where are the hundreds and hundreds of thousands of people really demanding this change?
LEÓN: Although 2013 came to a close without any immigration reform passed by Congress, The Real News will continue to report on this important issue throughout 2014.
Reporting for The Real News, this is Oscar León.
by Oscar Leon February 15, 2013 for TRNN
Sheriff Arpaio of Maricopa County Arizona, accused of brutal law enforcement and racial profiling; faces a recall campaign from an independent coalition.
by Oscar Leon June 2, 2013 for TRNN
Mobilization across the country demands Obama administration stop deportations and pass genuine immigration reform
CROWD: When communities are under attack, what do we do? Stand up, fight back!
OSCAR LEÓN, TRNN PRODUCER: Human Rights organizations and immigrant rights activists held a week of action in many cities around the country to demand a halt to all deportations.
Since the National Action Day for Immigration Reform on April 10, Latino activists and families have organized a number of actions in order to build up political pressure, while Democrats and Republicans debate about immigration reform in the Senate and eventually in the House of Representatives in U.S. Congress. On one side, Senate Democratic Leader Harry Reid declared Wednesday on an interview in Nevada’s Public TV, “it should be pretty easy to get four more Republican votes needed to pass the Senate 60-vote threshold.” Reid’s optimism contrasts with Democrat Senator Bob Menedez’s opinion. The chairman of the Senate Committee on Foreign Relations recently said that “Immigration reform doesn’t have 60 Senate votes.” Furthermore, the Senate’s eventual bill is not expected to pass the House. It has been reported that House Speaker John Boehner has insisted that “the Senate bill would not pass the House,” which he said “would craft its own immigration reform bill.”
Without many certainties about the final immigration reform bill that the president would eventually sign into law, while deportations planes leave the country every day in record numbers, human rights organizations, churches, and Latino families are feeling doubts and insecurity about their living situation, motivating them to speak out and demonstrate on the streets around U.S. in an effort to influence the debate on Capitol Hill.
On Wednesday, May 29 in Chicago, Latino rights advocates and activists joined environmental groups and chained themselves outside a fundraiser party to support Democrats running for the House on the next elections, hosted by Barack Obama–or “deporter in chief”, as they call him. There Rahm Emanuel, Nancy Pelosi, and many other Democrats had reportedly paid between $1,000 to $5,000 dollars to meet and lunch with the president.
ACTIVIST: We’re here to demand that Obama stop deportations. He has the power to stop deportations, and we believe in him to be able to do it, and we won’t stop until he stops deporting our families every single day.
LEÓN: The activists managed to hang a banner denouncing Obama’s record number of deportations outside the Hilton Chicago. But security forces rapidly took it down. The organization used a number of snowplows to block the hotel’s first floor windows, this to protect the people inside from a possible sniper fire.
In the southwest of the country, Arizona is one of the main fronts in this conflict between undocumented immigrants and authorities, who are trying to deport them back to their countries of origin. Many families are separated by deportation processes every day, like the Hernandez family, the focal center of Wednesday’s march. When a group of activists demonstrated outside the offices of Immigration and Custom Enforcement agency, there they demanded the release of Bertha Alicia Avila, who after being detained at a checkpoint in front of her daughters has been locked up for six months, with no right to bail, waiting for deportation in a cell at Eloy Detention Center, near Casa Grande Arizona, a private for-profit facility with a high rate of inmate fatalities.
JENNIFER HERNANDEZ, PHOENIX, ARIZONA: My dad has tried to get other people, like lawyers, and tried to do stuff with my mom, but since there’s been no response, there’s been no action taken with my mom, I mean, she just waits where she’s detained. And so we decided to take action in our own hands, and we decided to march today to make noise about my mom, to tell people that she exists, that she’s just not another number on a paper, that she has feelings, she has a family, and she has to be here with us. I mean, just because [incompr.] documentation, she’s not able for six months, almost seven, not be with us. It’s hard.
CARLOS AVILA, PHOENIX, ARIZONA: Like, I never really seen–never, like–I never really thought anything would happen to us, ’cause it just didn’t. Never came up. It’s just there. And it’s heard to–I’ve heard of it happening to other people, but when it happened to us, I just–I didn’t know what to do. I just want it to [incompr.] just be there. I really didn’t know how to act. I just wanted–.
LEÓN: The next day, on Thursday May 30, the famous sheriff Joe Arpaio dodged an attempt to force a recall election. The activist organizations looking to recall the sheriff were not able to gather the 335,000 valid voter signatures, despite the fact that he was recently found guilty of racial profiling by a federal court.
While Arpaio said he will appeal the court ruling, for the time being he has ordered his deputies to obey the court and stop arresting undocumented immigrants.
JOE ARPAIO, SHERIFF, MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA: You know as sheriff I uphold the law. The court’s order is now clear. We will no longer detain persons believed to be in the country without authorization whom we cannot arrest on state charges. I have already instructed my deputies.
LEÓN: In Miami, Florida, a couple dozen activist holding signs of “act now pass immigration reform” demonstrated outside U.S. Representative Trey Radel’s offices. Radel, a Republican representing Florida in Congress, can be a key vote in the heated dispute of the Senate.
The same day in Wisconsin, a group of activists and immigration advocates held a rally at U.S. Senator Johnson’s office. In Portland, there was a journey of fasting on Thursday and Friday.
ACTIVIST: We are part of the National Day Labor Organizing Network. We have this national fast, we call Not One More.
ACTIVIST: I am fasting to help send a message to stop the deportations of immigrants, because I believe that no human being is illegal.
LEÓN: On Thursday, May 30, many other families confronted and demanded Maricopa County’s attorney Bill Montgomery to release their relatives.
UNIDENTIFIED: You’re going out of your way to make sure that these people can’t even fight their immigration case. They’re not eligible to get an immigration bond because of the charges you’re giving them.
LEÓN: Bill Montgomery has acquired fame of being tough on immigration for presenting charges of conspiration to smuggle themselves for undocumented people otherwise not offenders.
UNIDENTIFIED (TRANSLATED): My kids, they need him.
LEÓN: This has been a widely criticized policy in Maricopa county that has prevented many individuals to make bail when arrested. Put in place in 2007 and ratified by Arizona’s senate on April 12, 2011, this policy ensures jail terms for undocumented immigrants before being deported back to their countries.
Perhaps one of the most effective ways to involve people in the undocumented Latino rights movement is art, like the one of Favianna Rodriguez, who has been working on ways to change the perception tagged on immigrants.
FAVIANNA RODRIGUEZ, ACTIVIST AND ARTIST: The anti-immigrants had this frame that said illegal, illegal, illegal. And then undocumented youth came and kicked that frame off, and they say, actually, we’re undocumented and we’re unafraid.
ACTIVIST: –and against deportations. This moment will not come again. If we settle for less, it will mean years and years of struggle to attain–.
LEÓN: On Friday, May 31, a group called the Tampa Dream Defenders rallied outside the local office of Republican Senator Marco Rubio, who faces criticism for a series of comments he made (as was reported by Reuters) recalling a meeting between republican senators. He said, “This is a terribly flawed bill, but it moves the ball forward, and over the next weeks and months, it will move ever rightward.”
Another Republican senator, Ted Cruz, a conservative from Texas who had introduced an amendment to block any access to citizenship to undocumented immigrants, was also confronted this week when about a hundred activists turned out in Manhattan when Cruz attended a Republican Party meeting in NY. In Philadelphia, also on Friday, about two dozen people gathered outside Governor Corbett’s office to remind him “that we came out in large numbers for our community members and the issues that matter to us,” as one of them told The Inquirer, a local newspaper, referring to their numbers in the last electoral process.
Many more actions are programmed to keep building political momentum, seeking to pressure the congressmen and senators to pass the immigration reform bill. They want legislation not only focused on securing the border and tightening controls, but one with a humane perspective that will satisfy the Latino community aspirations, mainly by stopping deportations, and in some cases even setting up bail for some people waiting for due process like Bertha Alicia Avila.
Reporting from Phoenix Arizona for The Real News, this is Oscar León.
by Oscar Leon June 24, 2013 for TRNN
Pt 1. In 2012, undocumented immigrants toured country on Undocubus, used civil disobedience campaign to mobilize support for just immigration reform
OSCAR LEÓN, TRNN PRODUCER: A group of activists from Phoenix, Arizona, organized a bus trip for undocumented voluntaries as part of a wider campaign called No Papers, No Fear, trying to bring the drama of undocumented people’s life to the public attention and trying to empower the Latino community. Last year they toured parts of the Midwest and the Southwest Coast on the way to Charleston, North Carolina, where after 20 cities on ten states, the first chapter of the trip ended. The bus is now headed to California, touring the West Coast.
FERNANDO LOPEZ, COMMUNITY RIGHTS ACTIVIST: The purpose was to, like, gather as many people possible, you know, that they have, like, open cases or, like, just regular people that, you know, they risk arrest every day just by going out on the street, you know, to drop off their kids or going to get groceries or whatever. So we just wanted to show that for a lot of people it was–they saw it as something really risky just to get on a bus and, you know, openly say they were undocumented and travel across country. But it’s something that we do every day. You know, we’re under that risk.
LEÓN: A positive outcome from the battle for undocumented people’s right here in Phoenix Arizona is a sizable Latino rights movement composed by people from different backgrounds.
Many of them gathered together to paint their bus and got it ready to go.
UNIDENTIFIED: This bus stands for not being afraid, and for being proud of who you are, and for seeing the beauty in the lives of the people who are told that they’re undocumented so they must be in the shadows. But the bus is supposed to carry that message that, no, you don’t have to be in the shadows.
LOPEZ: In reality there is nothing to fear to come out and say, you know, openly that you’re undocumented, because you’re still under the same risk, you know, of getting arrested or getting pulled over and not having an ID.
LEÓN: On August 1, 2012, under a full moon, they hit the road and drove north for about 12 hours from Phoenix to Denver. Once in Colorado, the first stop of the trip, the activists met with local Latino rights organizations and discussed strategies to unite and coordinate efforts.
ERIKA OVALLE, COMMUNITY RIGHTS ACTIVIST: I play a supportive role when they do civil disobedience. We do a lot of the chanting and stuff. So we get people’s energy up. And everybody did a great job. And I don’t have any children, but, you know, I see so many faces, I see so many kids out there who are–they’re hurting. Even today at our action, so many broken people. You know, they might arrest one person, but the family outside is suffering. You know, the person inside is suffering. People are committing suicide. And a lot of private prisons, people are investing in our incarceration. And to me that just blows my mind.
LEÓN: The next day, on August 3, they arrived to Albuquerque, New Mexico, and met with local Native American and Latino activists to interchange experience and widen the network of activists and local organizations.
After a night of travel, they demonstrated in Travis County, Texas, where 50 local activists show support for the Undocubus. They called on the local sheriff, Craig Hamilton, to stop participating in the program that detains and deports illegal immigrants.
SARAHI URIBE, NATIONAL DAY LABOR ORGANIZING NETWORK: They’re mothers, they’re fathers, they’re day laborers, they’re workers, they’re students, and they’re drawing inspiration from the undocumented youth movement that has led the country forward. And throughout the country, the purpose of the riders is not only to overcome their fear, but to also pose a moral dilemma to sheriffs like Sheriff Hamilton, who claims he has no choice. But he does have a choice. And the riders are coming to Austin to pose that moral dilemma and have the sheriffs stand on the right side of history, to have the sheriffs stand with the riders and stand with the community. And that’s why they’ve come so far.
LEÓN: Many miles and cities down the road, the Undocubus visited New Orleans to talk about and understand the natural and humanitarian disaster that was Hurricane Katrina.
ALFRED MARSHALL, STAND WITH DIGNITY: It knocked these buildings down.
LEÓN: There they learn about an agreement between the black Stand with Dignity and Latino Congress of the Jornaleros coalitions. This union of coalitions was created to heal tensions between the two communities.
MARSHALL: You was talking about the border from Mexico to the United States. Here’s a border from my street, from one side of of the street to the next street. That is the border right there. I can’t even cross the street.
ELEAZAR CASTELLANOS, CONRGRESO DE JORNALEROS: It’s hard to live in a neighborhood that is separated by a single street. It makes me feel I am at the border, where some are declared legal while others aren’t.
LEÓN: On August 18 in Alabama, they demonstrated outside the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights. The Undocubus activists, or “riders”, as they call themselves, interrupted a testimony by Kris Kobach, one of the SB 1070 authors, who had been invited to speak about the impact of that law.
UNIDENTIFIED: The federal civil rights commission is having an audience, a hearing, and they’re inviting really racist people like Kris Kobach, like Dan Stein, like [incompr.] and people that hide behind the face of a business suit. But they’re still really racist people. They’re still the clan. It’s just that they’re wearing a suit.
LEÓN: He was invited because in 2012, Alabama followed the example of Arizona and enacted a very similar law, HB 56.
PROTESTER (SUBTITLED TRANSL.): Here I am raising my voice for my family, for my community and my children, for all the families that have been separated. I am doing this so you all see that I am a mother, a responsible mother. I am not a criminal. I am no criminal. I am here defending my rights.
PROTESTER: We love this country. We can share. We can share with you. But we can’t live with the lies. We are undocumented, but we are human, not animals.
LEÓN: In part two of this report we will ride with the Undocubus activists all the way to North Carolina in their quest to empower a community as a response to the criminalization of undocumented people.
Reporting for The Real News, this is Oscar León.
by Oscar Leon May 4, 2012 for TRNN
by Oscar Leon June 27, 2013 for TRNN
Pt 2. In 2012, undocumented immigrants launched the “Undocubus” campaign and used civil disobedience to challenge deportations
OSCAR LEÓN, TRNN PRODUCER: This is the second part of a report about a group of activists from Phoenix, Arizona, who organized UndocuBus, a bus trip for undocumented voluntaries, as a part of a wider campaign called No Papers, No Fear, trying to bring the drama of undocumented people’s life to the public attention and trying to empower the Latino community.
On part one we reviewed their trip, starting from Phoenix, crossing Colorado, Texas, Louisiana, and Alabama on their way to Charleston, North Carolina.
FERNANDO LOPEZ, COMMUNITY RIGHTS ACTIVIST: But it’s just to show, like, the power that an organized community has, and then also to build a network. We have all this technology these days. You know, we have internet, we have Facebook, we have cell phones. We can all use that to organize.
The other purpose was showing what an organized community can do. You know. Like, we were, like, so many and we had so much support that it didn’t really matter that we were saying we were undocumented, traveling in a bus that said that we had no papers on the outside.
LEÓN: One of the main stops was on August 22 in Atlanta, a city with a big Latino population and a powerhouse for the economy among southern states. There the UndocuBus “riders”, supported by numbers of local activists, demonstrated outside Atlanta City Detention Center, one of the jails where undocumented individuals are detained under Georgia’s HB87 law, sometimes for long periods of time before being deported.
ERIKA OVALLE, COMMUNITY RIGHTS ACTIVIST: When we went to different stops, people did–they were very interested in Arizona. So when we got to Atlanta, it was like, wow, Arizona’s here, you guys are the leaders in this fight, we look up to you. And, you know, we more or less were like, well, we’re all in it together. But they see a lot of our actions, so they were really inspired by it.
LEÓN: In Atlanta, like the other cities, the “riders” visited a rally on Latino markets and communities spreading their message of strength in community organizing.
After leaving Georgia and crossing into Tennessee, they visited the National Museum of Civil Rights. Many riders blogged that they became inspired by the tactics and beliefs of the community organizers who changed history and society by relying precisely on what the “riders” have been preaching from day one–community strength.
Tennessee is one of the many states that followed Arizona’s SB 1070 and passed a similar bill, HB 670.
OVALLE: —Arizonification. So there were checkpoints, there where sheriffs who didn’t want to talk to the people. It was very, very similar to here, but still really, really backward. Like, here at least we will fight, we’ll get to the media, we’ll do what we have to do. But in a small town like Knoxville, it was a lot more difficult.
CROWD: Undocumented! [incompr.]
OVALLE: In Knoxville, Tennessee, actually, it was very, very interesting there, because that was the first time I had ever done civil disobedience where they tried to actually kill us. They wanted to run us over. And that was unlike anything I had ever experienced, even here in Arizona. I mean, they get–people get angry. But in Tennessee they wanted to run us over. As soon as we took that street, they were ready. And so that was a little bit interesting and scary to me. We stopped at a four-corner, and we were in the middle of the intersection, and we blocked off traffic so bad that it was really backed up. And we had a forum, like, a body of chain to protect the people in the middle, because they wanted to run us over. They didn’t care. They were like, get out of the street, and if you don’t go–they were, like, gearing up, like rrrngh. Like, they were just ready for us.
LEÓN: The riders made their way to nightly newscasts after a very tense action of civil disobedience, where four of them were arrested and later released.
Many of the UndocuBus activists who took part of that action were people that back in Arizona were afraid of any contact with the police. Now they were here, voluntarily risking arrest and maybe deportation.
LOPEZ: I don’t know. You just think about every time people were doing civil disobedience. You know, like, they were undocumented people that at some time they were afraid of even, like, engage–any kind of engagement with the cops, then seeing that they were, you know, shutting down streets and saying–being willing to get arrested for the cause. So I think that’s something really, like, that caused a lot of impact, you know, like, seeing how just education, just knowing about basic laws and or basic rights, it could give you, like, so much empowerment, you know, even though the system is telling you that you’re undocumented, you don’t have a voice, you can’t vote. You still have a voice, you know, if you organize with the community.
LEÓN: On Sylva, North Carolina, the activists visited the local police station trying to confront Sheriff Jimmy Ashe, who regularly set up checkpoints in Latino neighborhoods where many workers of the numerous local plantations live. A group of local activists and “riders” walked in and showed no fear inside the police station.
~~~
REPRESENTATIVE OF SHERIFF JIMMY ASHE: The sheriff’s not here. Would you like to speak with a deputy or–?
PARTICIPANT, NO PAPERS, NO FEAR CAMPAIGN: Do you have an idea when he’ll be returning?
REPRESENTATIVE OF SHERIFF JIMMY ASHE: What you have to do is make an appointment, ’cause I don’t know.
~~~
KITZIA ESTEVA, BUS RIDER UNION MEMBER: Hello, Sheriff Jimmy Ashe. This is Kitzia Esteva from the No Papers, No Fear right for justice. And I’m calling you because we’re trying to have a meeting with you and we’re waiting for you here. So we want to talk to you about why you should do that.
PARTICIPANT, NO PAPERS, NO FEAR CAMPAIGN: And we are here in your office. We want to meet with you in order to talk about some issues that are happening here in the community, in the country.
~~~
PARTICIPANT, NO PAPERS, NO FEAR CAMPAIGN: We’re here to talk to the sheriff if that’s at all possible.
LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICIAL: He’s not available. Is there anything else I can help you with? Or–.
PARTICIPANT, NO PAPERS, NO FEAR CAMPAIGN: Well, we’d like to speak to someone, because there’s some concerns here in the local community and the sheriff hasn’t been willing to speak to folks.
LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICIAL: Okay. Put the camera down. That’s–.
~~~
LEÓN: The trip ended in North Carolina. After traveling for over a month, on September 2 the UndocuBus arrived to Charleston and closed it’s journey protesting the Democratic National Convention. There they received the support of a number of local activists.
ESTEVA: –my mother. [incompr.] doesn’t help my mother. If we are arrested today and she gets arrested, she’s receiving deportation. But we’re here because we want to stop that, exactly that, the separation of families. And we have faith that our action is going to have ripple effect in all of our communities, that they’re going to organize to get us out and to continue fighting.
CROWD: Undocumented! [incompr.]
UNIDENTIFIED (SUBTITLED TRANSL.): I need for President Obama to hear our message. What side is he on? Does he want to be remembered as one who deported undocumented people? Or does he want to be on the side of immigrants and their civil rights?
~~~
ROSARIO DAWSON, ACTRESS: For all of you who just got arrested, I just want to commend your bravery in making sure that your voices, your stories, your situation is exposed and shown, that it’s not just about what people, big people with a lot of money and Super PACs get to say out in the media and the press, but that real people step forward and share their stories unafraid. You should not be afraid, even though you’re undocumented. Things will change. We are here with you. Si se puede!
CROWD: Si se puede!
~~~
OVALLE: I think we’re living in extreme times. And since we’re living in extreme times, we need extreme measures. We’re dealing with mass incarceration and a mass amount of criminalization. And we’re a society that punishes and tortures one another because we feel like we can judge. And that’s not the truth. You know, as long as the government goes around and starts saying, well, you’re a criminal, you’re not, you’re not, you know we can’t allow that to happen. Our community is broken, our families are broken, and it’s breaking us as individuals.
LEÓN: UndocuBus is one of many initiatives by the immigrant, mainly Latino advocates to bring their daily drama of racial profiling and separation of families to the public eye. Other initiatives, like Immigration Is Beautiful and Coming Out of the Shadows add to this No Papers, No Fear campaign. The idea behind them is to empower individuals through community organizing.
Reporting for The Real News this is Oscar León.
by Oscar Leon March 12, 2013 for TRNN
Protest organized by families broken by immigration deportations
OSCAR LEON, PRODUCER, TRNN: Many Latino rights organizations have declared the month of March as the month of action for real immigration reform across the United States. In cities around the country, families and activists have taken to the streets to show support and solidarity with the many families of these broken homes. In Flagstaff, Arizona, on Saturday, people defied the snow and low temperatures to bring attention to this daily drama.
In Chicago on Sunday, a march called “Coming Out of the Shadows” took place. A couple of hundred of activists gathered downtown. Around 100 people marched on Monday, 11 March, in downtown Phoenix to demand the end of deportations and separations of families with undocumented members. This march takes place in a month that has been declared a month of action for real immigration reform by many Latino rights organizations across the United States. Erika Andiola felt the pain and fear herself when ICE agents broke in her house, detaining her mom and her brother. Fortunately for her, the community’s support and phone calls got her family released.
ERIKA ANDIOLA, DREAM ACTION COALITION: People that are detained in jail for years, that their–the only crime (which I don’t think is a crime) committed was really providing for their family, going to work. You know, sometimes you have to find ways to work if your family’s going through a rough time. And so Arizona’s one of the harshest–or Maricopa County’s one of the harshest places to just work. And, you know, people are in jail for years just for doing that. And, you know, we want to be able to avoid that. And if Arizona can be a starting place for people to realize that this is wrong, then hopefully that can be a blueprint; that fact, that they stopped that, can be a blueprint for the rest of the country.
LEON: The reunification of people that has been detained and put in deportation process is being used lately as some other families were successful in their effort to recover their loved ones by putting public pressure on local elected and public officials. That is why in this little theater montage, the activists try to teach the use of a cellular phone and social media as an effective tool for garnering community support and defend their neighbors and family in case of a raid by ICE or the feared Maricopa sheriff, Joe Arpaio.
ACTIVIST (SUBTITLED TRANSL.): Bring out your cellular phones so we can call ICE and free this friend. She needs our help.
UNIDENTIFIED: Inside this building, a terrible–while I was in there, they keep you in a room with 40-plus other males. It’s really cold. They try to keep the temperatures as low as possible to prevent bacteria and infections and, you know, diseases. But while I was in there–they usually give blankets to cover up ’cause it’s so cold. But while I was in there, there was a bedbug breakout. So I was then exposed to that. There was a bedbug breakout. We didn’t receive any blankets.
JORGE MARTINEZ (SUBTITLED TRANSL.): We are tired of all that is happening here in Arizona and all across the U.S. We want them to stop deporting people. We have so many of us being deported day after day after day. I myself am in a deportation process. I don’t know what is going to happen. My son is detained and on deportation process. We are trying to get him out. But you know lawyers charge high prices to defend immigration cases here in Arizona.
I was sent for 30 days to a detaining center, which in reality is a prison, a private prison rented by ICE where they treat you really bad. There I observed very unfair treatment. The county sheriff maltreated the prisoners, and especially with the services, like food. We were fed really horrible food: raw rice and raw beans. It was horrible. Many people got sick. I was one of them.
Some people got arrested while crossing the border. Many of them arrived to jail badly beaten. They said it was the agents who did it. None of them got a chance to defend themselves or undergo any sort of procedure. They were deported right away. The incident that especially got my attention was of this guy who was beaten. He had a badly injured eye. He got taken away without any medical help or lawful procedure. He got deported to Guatemala.
LEON: After walking for miles under the hot desert sun, the march came to an end outside Maricopa County attorney’s–Bill Montgomery’s office.
MIGUEL GUERRA (SUBTITLED TRANSL.): We are against these new lawsthat are being passed here in Arizona. We want them to change the kind of charges made against people that are being detained in Arpaio’s raids. We want to tell Bill Montgomery to redraw all the harsh sentences (on immigrants). I think it is unfair the way they separate families. Inside the ICE jail I saw how they do it. They intimidate them into signing their deportation papers, saying that if they don’t sign, they’ll remain from six to 12 months in jail.
LEON: Montgomery’s hard sentences on Latinos either with fake IDs or working without legal documents are a major factor in the separation of families.
JULIA OJEDA (SUBTITLED TRANSL.): There was an Arpaio raid, and they took my husband. His name is Miguel Venegas. And we are here to demand our rights as human beings. We are not criminals. We are hardworking people that come to this country to fight for a better life, and our children belong here. We want them to stop deportations and to drop the charges no all the raided workers that were detained (with my husband).
JHONTE VENEGAS, 15-YEAR-OLD: And I’m here to tell Montgomery to drop the charges, ’cause we don’t like it to–Montgomery to part the families. And we want all the families together, to be happy. And I fear Arpaio took my dad when he was at work, and I was devastated that he took my dad. And it’s been hard that my dad’s not here. He was working hard to put food on the table for my family. And I just want him back home.
LEON: The demonstration was carried out on Monday morning, a day that’s normally not known to attract big crowds because everybody’s working or studying. However, they did it this way ’cause they wanted the public officers inside the buildings to feel the pressure by themself, since on Saturday they’re not working.
After making a lot of noise both outside the county’s building and in the TV news, these families and activists went back to their lives. Many of them, however, went back to homes that are lacking one or more members.
More marches and events are set up to happen all across the country in this month of action for immigration rights.
For The Real News, this is Oscar Leon.
by Oscar Leon November 1, 2010 for TRNN
One day before the election and voters in Arizona are more focused on immigration and drug crime than on unemployment and housing foreclosures.
by Oscar Leon February 10, 2011 for TRNN
TRNN visits a gun store in Tucson
OSCAR LEON, TRNN: On the aftermath of the Tucson shootings, I still had Sheriff Dupnik’s declarations in mind.
CLARENCE DUPNIK, SHERIFF, PIMA COUNTY, AZ: It’s my feeling that his personality is the type that is susceptible to this kind of behavior. It doesn’t surprise me that people from the right would be upset that people like myself and maybe people from the left and a whole lot of other people in America feel as I do, that the anger that’s purposely generated by people who make a living off of it serves one particular party better than the others. And it wouldn’t surprise me if it continues at least through 2012.
LEON: So when I heard there was a movement to recall the sheriff, I drove to Tucson. In the Black Weapons Armory, I found some of the sheriff’s apposers. However, they did not allow me to film the petition to depose the sheriff or the people who sign it. I end up talking to the shop owner and a guns / martial arts instructor to figure out their perspective on gun laws, the Second Amendment, and the shooting.
JEFFREY PRATHER, WEAPONS & MARTIAL ARTS INSTRUCTOR: As far as Dupnik, Sheriff Dupnik is concerned, he–as a former law enforcement official myself, I thought he acted very unprofessionably and irresponsibly, because he had no facts to back up what he said whatsoever. And a good defense attorney–and I’ve been to trial with a lot of cases–is going to bring his remarks up in court and say that the prosecution is prejudicial because of that attitude. He is in effect profiling anybody who is conservative, pro-gun, Republican. And I foresee a lot of problems for him in future court cases and inside his own department, with promotions and hiring and equal opportunity lawsuits where I see officers coming forward and saying, well, you didn’t give me a promotion because I was a conservative and I was on this Facebook or this blog or something. I think Sheriff Dupnik should pay a lot more attention to law enforcement and a lot less to publicity.
~~~
LEON: Have there been any kind of modifications to the procedures you have to do in order to sell a gun?
TOM ROMPEL, BLACK WEAPONS ARMORY OWNER: No, none whatsoever. The requirements are that if you want to purchase a handgun, you must be an Arizona resident. Assuming you’re an Arizona resident, you would then fill out a one-page federal form. It’s called a 4473. Once you have that completed, we copy your example, your driver’s license with your current address. We call in to ATF [Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives] or FBI for a background check, which takes about two or three minutes. Assuming that you are clear, they give us the proceed. Then we can proceed with the transaction and you can take your firearm, your handgun out right away. Well, the Second Amendment–our founding fathers, when they drafted the Constitution of the United States, put the Second Amendment in there. Second Amendment deals with the right of a US citizen to keep and bear arms. Now, they did that to prevent a tyrannical government. So they believed that a government should fear their people, the people should not fear the government. And that is the brilliance–one of the things our founding fathers did. And that is actually the culture of what it is to be a US citizen.
~~~
PRATHER: Second Amendment’s right there in our pocket Constitution: “the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed”. And what that means is that the average citizen is allowed to defend themselves against tyranny of oppressive government, against criminals, against domestic or foreign terrorists. Well, Arizona has always been a bastion of Second Amendment freedom. And if you’re paying attention to American politics right now, Arizona is the epicenter of individual rights and states rights, where we are opposing big government, big government restrictions, and emphasizing individual and states rights, including gun rights, because if you aren’t free–. The reason we’re free is not because we talk about it. The reason is is because we’re armed and able to defend it. And since the history of the beginning of the United States our founding fathers defended themselves with firearms. In fact, the Continental Army fought against the British before there was even a country founded. Early native Americans defended their freedom with firearms. Early African Americans defended their freedom with firearms. And that’s just a fact of life is if you want to be free, you have to be willing to fight for it, and the weapon of the age is the firearm.
ROMPEL: Government has no business controlling guns. The only reason they want to control it is so they can control the populace. You can look around the globe. Where citizens are unarmed, you–Venezuela, someone not far from your own native country, is a great example where the citizenry has been disarmed, and now you have a dictator in South America. Of course, he calls himself a president. I’m talking about Hugo Chavez. So the government does not have a right to control the firearms. There is no proposal on the floor that I have heard of at this point to control the firearms. If anyone tries that, there is going to be fierce opposition in Washington on the congressional floor. Well, there is–on the form itself, if you have been hospitalized or had been evaluated for mental problems, then you’re prohibited from purchasing a firearm. I think our gun laws are fine the way they are. It’d be nice for our government to focus on other issues, like illegal immigration. And our government needs to enforce the laws that are on the book and not worry about an issue like Second Amendment. Well, we have some very unique issues. We’re a border state. The majority of the drug trafficking is coming right through just south of here. We know for a fact our border is porous. We’re being overrun. And our federal government is not doing anything. They’re looking the other way.
PRATHER: Well, again, the Second Amendment starts off by saying “a well regulated militia”, and the reason for that at the time was because when the United States of America was being founded, there really was no United States Army yet. There was a Continental Army, and George Washington was leading the Continental Army, but in local areas they were militias. Militia took on a dirty word under the Clinton administration, and there is kind of a connotation of big-bellied, camouflaged, cut-off sleeves, backwoods types. But actually the history of America is founded on militias, local communities, local citizen patriots defending themselves from the British with their firearms. And, again, that’s what happened on that Saturday is you could say that those folks were an unorganized militia. They came together right there for the event, and all those people worked together–you know, retired colonel Bill Badgers arm-barring the guy down, 61-year-old Patricia [inaudible] [Maisch] grabbing his magazine, Joe Zamudio drawing his weapon and then holstering it, Daniel Hernandez keeping pressure on Congresswoman Giffords’ head wound. Certainly, if he had not done that, she probably wouldn’t be making the miraculous progress. But everybody worked together immediately as a citizen militia. And it was an armed militia. Joe Zamudio was armed. He just didn’t need to shoot. So the concept of militia has been badmouthed. And now we normally call them state national guards, as in the Arizona National Guard. But I believe, if I’m not mistaken, there is still an Arizona law on the books that every adult male from age 18, I think, to 42, maybe, is in the Arizona militia and it can still be called up. And, again, the best kind of government is local government. Nobody knows how to govern themselves best than local people. This whole big-government concept that people in Washington or people in the UN can best know what’s best for us in different places is absurd. And militia shouldn’t be a dirty word at all.
LEON: For The Real News, this is Oscar Leon..
by Oscar Leon January 14, 2011 for TRNN
TRNN speaks to people attending memorial service in Tucson
OSCAR LEON (VOICEOVER), TRNN: On January 8, in the corner of West Ina Road and Oracle in suburban Tucson outside a Walgreens store, a gunman suddenly unleashed hell on the people that attended an event called “Congress on Your Corner”. Jared Loughner shot Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords in the head before killing six other people. Congresswoman Giffords survived the attack. As America felt the shock, one of the voices that were most revealing was the one of Sheriff Clarence Dupnik, a personal friend of Giffords and Judge John McCarthy Roll.
SHERIFF CLARENCE DUPNIK, PIMA COUNTY, ARIZONA: But again I’d just like to say that when you look at unbalanced people, how they are–how they respond to the vitriol that comes out of certain mouths about tearing down the government, the anger, the hatred, the bigotry that goes on in this country is getting to be outrageous. And, unfortunately, Arizona, I think, has become sort of the capital. We have become the mecca for prejudice and bigotry.
LEON: After these strong statements by the sheriff, I attended the event “Together We Thrive” to find out what the Tucsonians have to say about this.
UNIDENTIFIED: Yeah, I do think the media has had a negative impact on everything that’s been going on here. And the TV, definitely. It’s, like, very different here lately when it comes to politics. It’s been very different. And for us, that we live here.
UNIDENTIFIED: No, I think it’s very out of hand, and I think that Sheriff Dupnik spoke the truth when he said that we need to tone down the tearing down the government, we need to tone down the hatred and animosity, ’cause it doesn’t do anything for anybody, it doesn’t bring any help. And that’s a big part of the reason why we came down here today, to support, to try and bring the city back together.
UNIDENTIFIED: It has become a mecca for racism, bigotry, and hatred. It’s divided friends and neighbors. It’s been that heated. I personally within the past couple of years have felt the–you just feel the whole pressure, the whole negativity across–everywhere you go.
UNIDENTIFIED: It could happen anywhere. So, I mean, I don’t know why it’s fair to say the political “mecca” even, ’cause why does Mecca have anything to do with this?
UNIDENTIFIED: Politics in Arizona are absolutely crazy beyond all belief. Tucson, I feel like, is more a mellow, you know, more liberal city. You know, Phoenix is where things like this happen.
UNIDENTIFIED: I think considering this year’s election it’s justified to say that, how much propaganda and lies there were behind the candidates that were running. But I’d say overall we’re not the capital of bigotry. I think there’s other states that represent that better than Arizona. I’d say if gun laws continue to get more lax, it’s definitely–there’s potential for there to be more problems, like, considering how lax the gun laws already are. But at the same time, I think it’s everyone’s responsibility to learn the responsibility that comes with owning a gun. I don’t necessarily think that owning a gun leads to this sort of thing. I think it’s the person behind the gun. I think the media has a lot to do with the animosity that people feel towards the government also, just because there’s so much propaganda with the right and the left, especially in Arizona.
UNIDENTIFIED: I feel safe in America, but there’s just a lot of people out–there’s a certain few out there who just don’t like us, and it’s hurting America as a whole.
UNIDENTIFIED: I would say maybe in other parts of Arizona, but not in Tucson. People are generally really cool with one another out here. I’ve found it to be a very accepting and just a great place to live. I didn’t have–. But I do know what the sheriff was talking about. That sort of vitriol he was speaking of is definitely permeated some of Arizona politics.
UNIDENTIFIED: But I don’t think Tucson is the capital. But the United States has a lot of rhetoric and vitriol right now within politics, and I think right now it’s a time to reflect on the attitudes that both parties have. I think it’s–we–both parties should reflect on their behaviors and we should change our attitudes toward parties. We shouldn’t see each other as enemies but friends working together.
UNIDENTIFIED: I think Sheriff Dupnik said the right things. I think, you know, that does capture a feeling of a lot of our community. And this gentleman, you know, obviously he was mentally ill. Whether he was motivated by politics or not I don’t know, but it certainly didn’t help it, because the things that are being said in the political arena are very negative and very aggressive, and I’m sure that contributes to it.
UNIDENTIFIED: I think we all have our preconceived notions of people. And when the media is portraying people in a bad light, it’s very easy to make our emotions double, you know, to increase them in intensity, possibly even leading someone to do something like what happened here. You know, in the proximity that we are to Mexico and with all of the racial tensions that are around here, I absolutely think that we are the center of it. You never hear people complaining about Canadians who are immigrating here; it’s always Hispanic people. And I think that we are indeed the very center of the problem here, of the political heat for immigration.
UNIDENTIFIED: I think it is. It is. There’s so much hatred with living on the border. The whole immigration issues, everything that’s happening right now, the whole eyes, news, everything is here in Arizona. And that’s probably true. Just before the shooting, you had the big incident happening on the border with a border patrol agent shooting a 15- or 16-year-old kid crossing from Nogales, Sorona, to Nogales, Arizona. So, I mean, I think that kind of sparked, and now this is happening, so it could be.
UNIDENTIFIED (SUBTITLED TRANSLATION): The way that we as Latinos have been criminalized in Arizona, imagine if the shooter was Latino. We will be executed by now.
UNIDENTIFIED: I don’t know if it’s the capital, but things have gotten ugly. Things have definitely–politically, the language, the ideas that people are talking about are just getting too extreme, I think. There’s a culture of violence in this country, and gun–so many people have guns in this country. They are too easy to access.
UNIDENTIFIED: You know what? The media is doing its job. And it’s the government’s job to get out there and talk to the people, and I think Congresswoman Giffords was doing just that. And whether–I don’t think the media had a big influence on it. I think just with social networking and just how the Internet is with blogging, you can’t control that. That isn’t the media. That’s just everyday people going online and speaking their mind.
UNIDENTIFIED: I think there’s animosity. There’s definitely a lot of animosity in Arizona.
UNIDENTIFIED: I think we take the Constitution a little too much at heart, and they try and nitpick at every little thing, and just they’ve got to remember that everyone’s equal.
UNIDENTIFIED: I mean, I think Arizona as a state, being a state that allows you to conceal and carry a weapon pretty much anywhere, you know, including grocery stores and malls, things like that–bars you can conceal and carry a weapon–you know, that might be something that needs to be looked at a little bit more seriously when we have events that happen like this.
UNIDENTIFIED: I think it’s important for us to stop, look, and listen to what the community is saying and really listen to our people. And then we can make a change positively.
UNIDENTIFIED: –and it has nothing to do with politics, and he was completely wrong in his views on the issue. It’s one person that was violent, and he chose to act out in an unlawful way. So it has nothing to do with politics.
UNIDENTIFIED: For us, and not only for a lot of people in the country, but for a law enforcement official, specifically Clarence Dupnik, to politicize this before we knew anything about the individual I think really cast a bad shadow on Arizona.
UNIDENTIFIED: Just because people are drinking and driving doesn’t mean we make driving illegal or drinking illegal. I mean, just because a couple of people screw up doesn’t mean we should limit and restrain all the people that actually follow laws and abide by and are given and who have fought for our Second Amendment.
UNIDENTIFIED: I think the media does the best job that they are able to, but the whole truth is never portrayed in the idiot box. What happened to bring me your poor, your tired, your wretched masses, yearning to be free? And now it says “no vacancies”. Screw that. We can lose–like, we can lose the wall. We can lose the wall. Why don’t we just make it a state?
UNIDENTIFIED: City perhaps, but I also feel the Senate Bill 1070 brought a lot of negative animosity to groups of people, and now they’re–it gave them an incentive to come out and act in negative ways and say negative things and be racist. And maybe this is what caused Gabrielle Giffords and those other victims to undergo this tragedy.
‘Attrition by enforcement’ is the name of the game in Arizona. The goal is to dissuade undocumented immigration by making life unbearable for the undocumented already living in Arizona. Desert tent jails and arbitrary checkpoints are two of the tactics used to strike fear into the undocumented with the goal of deterring others from coming. Ecuadorian filmmaker Oscar Leon, who has been covering this issue from Arizona for the past three years, points out that the undocumented can’t possibly be separated from the documented Latino population without a police state, and Arizona has been developing it’s own version long before the controversial SB1070 law was on the map.
Produced by Jesse Freeston, August 2, 2010 for TRNN
by Oscar León August 5, 2018 for TRNN
Progressive grassroots candidates battle with Corporate Democrats for control of the party in Arizona
by Oscar León July 5, 2019 for TRNN
The revelation of extreme immigration detention center conditions for exhausted asylum seeking children, who are separated from their relatives, sparked outrage nationwide. In Phoenix, Arizona, Jews for Justice demonstrated, demanding permanent medical staff for Border patrol’s Provisional Detention Centers
by Oscar León July 7, 2019 for TRNN
A DHS Inspector General report and a visit by members of Congress to detention centers, the inhumane conditions become clearer and spark more outrage
by Oscar León June 23, 2018 for TRNN
Despite signing the end of family separation, “zero tolerance” policies are still in place, turning a decade long crisis into a larger problem
OSCAR LEON: Slowly but surely, the victims of the catastrophe we are witnessing began to recover their humanity, the very same humanity that Trump and so many white supremacists before him had worked so hard to deny.DONALD TRUMP: They’re not sending their best. They’re not sending you, they’re not sending you. They’re sending people that have lots of problems, and they’re bringing those problems with us. They’re bringing drugs, they’re bringing crime, they’re rapists. I’m going to build a wall, going to build a wall. We need the wall. And Mexico will pay for the wall. But we have some bad hombres here, and we’re going to get them out.OSCAR LEON: But the leaked audios of crying children tore the soul of the U.S. of A. and showed to the world a naked image of who really were these “bad hombres” fueling the rhetoric by the president. Univision Spanish’s reporters quickly found the aunt of “Alison,” one of the children we hear crying on the recording, and while she chose to remain anonymous, she said:AUNT OF ‘ALISON’: I feel great sorrow, my heart broke. She is my blood. I feel powerless. I spoke to her, and she told me everything that was happening, and I couldn’t do anything. As of now, we have no news of her either. We know she is in a shelter-detention institute. We have tried to follow up with them and they won’t give us any information about her, like where she is. My sister, who is detained in a different place, she does not know either.”OSCAR LEON: This picture by Getty Correspondent John Moore went viral as an instant classic of the dehumanization of those migrant families. Univision also found Denis Varela,the father of Janella Varela,the two-year-old little girl crying on the picture, the younger of four siblings and the one that made the trip with her mom.DENIS VARELA HERNANDEZ: The picture by photojournalist John Moore, it broke my soul. I can tell you my soul broke in pieces. To see my girl like that… right away I knew, I said, oh no!”OSCAR LEON: On Wednesday, president Trump signed an executive order that ended the separation of children but perpetuates indefinite incarceration and “zero tolerance” policies. However, the fact that the families will be kept together can make the world of a difference for the next wave of children, who like a hostage being released by its captor, will not face the ultimate torture as a welcome to the land of the free and the home of the brave.The policy of violence, incarceration and denial, conducted on cue by the maestro of showbiz, had begun leaving a trail that shook the hearts of everyone who listened to cry of the children. Infinite sadness quickly turned to rage.BOB INGRAM: Kidnapping of children crossing the border with their parents, and they are being held hostage for to build a wall. And I think that is abominable and un-American, and I think all Americans need to take every chance they can get and speak out against it.OSCAR LEON: Shadow Rock UCC and Central United Methodist Church, two progressive churches, called for a Father’s Day rally on Sunday, June 17.DOUG HANDLONG: My children go to their schools and see all shades of people. We are no longer just a white country, we are a melting pot of many different shades. So, that’s what our children see, that’s the lens they see through, is not just a pure white lens, but it’s various shades and colors. And it is a beautiful thing.OSCAR LEON: They called for a town hall meeting where many chosen speakers shared their first-hand experiences. The indignation towards Attorney General Jeff Sessions using the bible to justify child separation and imprisonment was still evidentMICHAEL STANCLIFF: Anybody can crib a biblical passage to support their position. The fact of the matter is that is if you want to talk about the bible, through the scriptures there is the command to be kind and to accept and to love immigrants.OSCAR LEON: Michael Stancliff, a scholar and activist and one of the organizers of the event.MICHAEL STANCLIFF: This is not an isolated incident. There are events, protests, vigils happening all over the country this week. And we are part of this movement to push back on these policies which recall the worst moments in United States history.People seem to be finally paying attention to what is a much broader problem, which is an immoral and dysfunctional immigration policy.OSCAR LEON: Germina Sanchez made this symbolic cage to carry in arms during the march.GERMINA SANCHEZ: I wanted to send a message for the community to realize the conditions under which kids are being held in detention centers. Those children are in a cage, and that to me is inhumane because they are children. I know of a number of families that have been separated, the dad taken away. And I feel an immense pain every time I hear about family separation.”OSCAR LEON: At the church town hall, people talked about the case of Marco Antonio Muñoz, thirty- nine years old from Honduras, who reportedly took his own life in a detention center on May 13 after his children were ripped away from his arms and he was placed in a padded cell. Many more cases were brought to bear, giving a name and a human identity to those often identified as “illegal aliens.” The people in attendance were outraged.SPEAKER ONE: I am a human, and what we are doing to these families is not human.SPEAKER TWO: I have two children of my own, and I would be extremely upset if they were to be ripped away from me as they are doing at the border.SPEAKER THREE: It is definitely a violation of human rights. Sadly, our history has had a lot of human rights violations, and this is unthinkable. I think people feel powerless, like what will it do if I yell and scream? But we have to, we have to do something. You can’t just walk by. And we can’t feel powerless, we have to do something, anything to force change, and awareness is first.OSCAR LEON But on the buildup to this point, not everybody was on board. In fact, this scene has been almost the same for over a decade; the indignation is new, the cages with families and children in them are not. J. Murieta is a security contractor, from Tucson, Arizona, I have personally meet before. Among other types of facilities, he has also worked on the Provisional Detention Centers. Responding to my inquiry, he wrote:J. MURIETA: I worked on three contracts with ICE and BP, and this was no different than the scene is now. I’m talking about it being over ten years ago. I worked those contracts. This isn’t new, nor is it only occurring due to the current administration. This happened in the Obama and Bush administrations and started with the Clintons.OSCAR LEON: The presence of unaccompanied minors in these detention centers for small periods of time has been a common occurrence over the past decade. A wave of unaccompanied children from Honduras, Nicaragua and El Salvador have been knocking on USA’s doors, feeing gang violence, escaping recruitment and assassination threats and poverty.These children, unlike past immigrant waves who avoided the Border Patrol), immediately surrender at US ports of entry, forcing its legal processing and release under any relative’s care if they had any. Thus, the presence of unaccompanied children at these facilities, an experience that Murieta, a hard man by any standards, who manned those facilities over the last decade and trains law enforcement in martial arts, described as “heartbreaking, to say the very least.” Murieta experienced how challenging it was to keep children and families detained, even for a short period of time. Trump’s executive order ends family separation but ensures indefinite detention.The recent escalations in number and severity of human rights violations is well documented and denounced by public and private organizations of a broad spectrum, foreign representatives and even the United Nations. The move by United States on Tuesday June 19 to abandon the UN Human Rights Council signals yet another step into a trend of human rights violations.DEMONSTRATORS: Say it loud, say it clear. Immigrants are welcome here.OSCAR LEON: From Phoenix Arizona, this is Oscar León.
by Oscar León June 27, 2018 for TRNN
Trump’s ‘zero tolerance’ immigration violation policy is not the only policy that is leading to family separations. Even families crossing at regular ports of entry and requesting asylum have often ended up being separated. Oscar Leon reports from Arizona
OSCAR LEON: While President Donald J. Trump says the gangs are invading USA, it seems to be that the ones arriving are the gangs’ victims. A wave of unaccompanied children from Honduras, Nicaragua and El Salvador have been knocking on USA’s doors, fleeing gang violence, escaping recruitment, assassination threats and poverty.PATRICIA FLORES: Firstly, the future of my son forced me to get out of El Salvador, because there is no future. So, I decided to leave my country because of the insecurity, the violence.OSCAR LEON: Differently from past migration waves with plans and intentions to avoid border patrol at all costs, large groups of families and even unaccompanied children take a great number of risks, just to get to a U.S. border checkpoint and ask for asylum. The zero-tolerance directive turns walking across the border into a crime and orders every state attorney to press mandatory criminal charges for those crossing the border. This means that those individuals will be immediately removed and sent to federal detention centers, and therefore cannot take care of children or minors accompanying them. The children and minors will be placed in the care of the U.S. Department of Health & Human Services, more exactly the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR).ANA MEJIA: That’s my biggest fear, to be separated from my children. I am bringing them, fleeing from the danger in Honduras. And if we are separated here in US, I don’t know what I would do. I think about this day and night when I see my children.OSCAR LEON: In the month that lasted the family separation policy, according to NPR, 2,342 children were taken away from their relatives and placed in detention centers for processing and eventual transfer to detention-care facilities. But even before the president backed down from his separation policy, some families had already been reunified thanks to the work of pro bono lawyers and advocates like the ones at the Florence Project, providing legal services to detained migrants and their families. Also, thanks to activists working with the Phoenix Restoration Project.SELENA KEESECKER: I worked with one woman, picked her up at the bus station one night- or one morning. She was supposed to take the bus to go to Florida, but she was not going to leave because her daughter was not with her. So, we took her home and we worked with the Phoenix Restoration, which we’re a part of, to find what we could do to find the daughter. And I made a number of calls over to UMA, because we heard that might be where she was, and no one in the UMA child’s department knew where she was. Talked to, left messages and talked to three different people and also another person, and they did not know where she was. And this child is a U.S. citizen, and I have no idea why they did not send that child to the family where this person eventually did go. She was a U.S. citizen born in California. She was about twelve years old, about twelve years old.OSCAR LEON: Cases like this are possible because unlike the people walking across the border, and because they are not fighting a criminal case but an immigration one, the people entering the country at ports of entry after initial processing and detention are entitled to seek asylum and have a legal opportunity to fight their cases in court, be released and even get to be reunited with their children here in U.S. pending their immigration cases. It is important to notice the difference between those who simply walk over the border and those who surrender themselves at ports of entry. The latter group “will not be prosecuted,” according to U.S. General Attorney Jeff B. Sessions, who, defending his immigration policy in Fox News, said:JEFF SESSIONS: If they enter the country at a port of entry, and there are many of those around the border, they are not violating the law. The mother or father in that circumstance will not be prosecuted, and the families will stay together. However, the lawyers from the Florence Project have observed that this is not the case and there have separations at ports of entry, as they confirmed to us in a written statement.FLORENCE PROJECT STATEMENT: The Florence Project is the only organization in Arizona providing free legal and social services to detained immigrants, including parents and children who have been separated. We have met with parents and children who were separated after seeking protection at a port of entry. We believe that the practice of forcibly separating families is cruel and inhumane.OSCAR LEON: As far as the people caught crossing the border with their children, they will be detained and charged, will face six months prison time, repeaters will face two years prison time, and after paying their sentences they will be deported.DOLORES ALARCON: We are each put in a cell that’s like a cage, the so-called “ICE machines.” It’s horribly cold. Us women are on the floor, there’s a piece of plastic over us and nothing else. For children, there is a mattress but there isn’t anything to cover you. And it’s very cold. We were there in detention for four days, my son and I, my husband also.OSCAR LEON: After the signing the executive directive to stop the separation of families, the Trump administration has offered a way for those parents who accept being deported to be sent back accompanied by their children. The ones who choose to stay and fight their cases in court, face a much more complicated path. Their children, at the care of Health and Human Services, will be trapped in detention centers, care institutions, until they are claimed. Veronica Monge, a local mom and activist, emphasizes the importance of supporting organizations that shelter and support these kids who can suffer even harder detention conditions, if they turn eighteen and they haven’t been claimed.VERONICA MONGE: After someone turns the age of eighteen, when they are released, if they don’t have anywhere to go, then they can be transferred to an adult detention center.OSCAR LEON: There is already a generation of American kids who have been severely impacted by family separation. Something that has happened since a decade ago, albeit different circumstances.VERONICA MONGE: I hear a lot of stories of separation, of families. A lot of people have relatives detained in Florence or in ICE detention.OSCAR LEON: Germina Sanchez, an activist from Central United Methodist Church, knows about a number of similar cases.GERMINA SANCHEZ: Those children face a very hard reality because they stay with an uncle, maybe an aunt or under the care of their older siblings. And it is very hard for someone so young to work and take care of them.OSCAR LEON: But why is this happening? Was an escalation in cruelty necessary? Is it necessary to stop immigration from the South? A growing economy relies on a growing population, and with birth rates in the U.S. reaching record lows in 2018 and in constant decline since 1971, economists suggest the future of the U.S. economy could rely on migrant population to keep up with its growth. In other words, a declining population could pose serious challenges in the future. So, the US economy needs all those future workers, shoppers and taxpayers to be able to maintain a functional economy of growth, never mind keeping its place as a world leader. But others, like Arizona State Representative David Stringer, see these kids as an “existential threat.”DAVID STRINGER: Sixty percent of children in public schools today are minorities, and that complicates racial integration because there aren’t enough white kids to go around. I mean look at that sixty percent number for our public-school students, just carry that forward ten years, fifteen years. It’s going to change the demographic voting base of the state and that’s what’s going on around the country”OSCAR LEON: Stringer speaks of the “the demographic voting base” around the country changing, and he is right. If you look at the demographic charts of the city of Phoenix, you’ll notice that after that generational shift takes place in fifteen years, it is easy to imagine that an anti-immigrant party can never win an election in a context of white people being a forty percent minority, as it is the case in the early ages brackets. With an endless flow of refugees percolating the South border, that difference could increase at an even larger rate. So, do they want to make a wall and imprison families indefinitely just so they can keep winning elections, even at the cost of their own country’s economic well-being? Stringer himself says it openly:DAVID STRINGER: Immigration is politically destabilizing the country, President Trump has talked about this. I am really concerned about this. Immigration today represents an existential threat to United States. If we don’t do something about immigration very, very soon, the demographics of our country will be irrevocably changed, and it will be a very different country. It will not be the country you were born into.OSCAR LEON: Which begs the question, does having a larger multiracial population assures electoral victories for the Democratic Party? It is not written in stone, especially because Democrats have separated about four million families already and those children that grew up with no father or mother, or both, will not forget as easily as the rest. For The Real News, from Arizona, this is Oscar León.
by Oscar León January 13, 2019 for TRNN
After Trump’s speech about the government shut down and funding for the wall, The Real News spoke with refugees waiting in Tijuana. Here’s what they said
NARRATOR: President Trump addressed a live television audience on January 8th. The context was the government shutdown over a funding for his promised border wall with Mexico.DONALD TRUMP: My fellow Americans, tonight I’m speaking to you because there is a growing humanitarian and security crisis at our southern border.NARRATOR: The Real News spoke to migrants from the central american caravan about the speech.MIGUEL ANGEL DELGADO (EL SALVADOR): My response is to ask him to open his heart, because what he is doing is very ugly. We just came here to work.JOSE MIGUEL (HONDURAS): [My response to Trump] is to ask him to give us a chance. Some of us are fleeing gang violence by the Maras [name of a gang] and all that.MARIA (HONDURAS): Everything he says is a lie. We come here to have a better future, to help our families. We aren’t going there to hurt anyone. We are travelling to improve our lives and for our families. Not to ruin anyone’s life or do bad things. We go there to work.JUAN DOE: I am bothered by it [Trump’s speech], because it is not true what he said. It is totally false what he says, we are not criminals, we are not a danger. What we want is to advance in life. We are fighters and we want to take care of our families.NARRATOR: This is “Juan Doe”, a father from Honduras who wishes to remain anonymous. He hasn’t seen his daughter in 5 months, and his voice is distraught.JUAN DOE (HONDURAS): I feel anguished, desperate. There are days… Every day I wake up feeling like going back to my country. Because the desperation of not being with my daughter drives me crazy. But she gives me strength to stay here and try to make it.”JOSE ALCEDO MACHADO (HONDURAS): He is trying to throw blame on immigrants, about things that immigrants don’t do. Maybe it has happened occasionally but we shouldn’t make everyone pay on account of one person.I think that all of this “caravan thing” is a political play from Honduras and the rest of the countries all the way north, to facilitate that 30% of the wall that Donald Trump wants.DONALD TRUMP: Over the years, thousands of Americans have been brutally killed by those who illegally entered our country and thousands more lives will be lost if we don’t act right now.This is a humanitarian crisis. A crisis of the heart, and a crisis of the soul. Last month, 20,000 migrant children were illegally brought into the United States, a dramatic increase.NARRATOR: Robert Vivar, is a US Veteran whose son is currently serving in the military. He took exception with President Trump’s words.ROBERT VIVAR: What he was saying does not go very well with me because what he is talking about instead of making America safer is making America more dangerous, because all he is doing is trying to stir up more hate, more fear in the public. And validating the fear of racism for more violent acts to be created against people that are not white.NARRATOR: Jonathan Gonzales said he was deported just 3 days before enlisting in the army. He thinks Trump is manipulating the facts to make immigrants look bad:JONATHAN GONZALES: I would use the term he uses all the time, ‘fake news’, that is what he did right now, he always talks about ‘fake news’. Why doesn’t he talk about the three girls that he raped, yet he talks about three girls that got raped by hispanic people. They got proof of that? He doesn’t.Why doesn’t he talk about the three children that just died like three [weeks] ago in ICE facilities? Why isn’t he talking about that? He is just not going to do it.ROBERT VIVAR: He talks about trafficking drugs, come on!That is just fear mongering, besides, does a regular drug runner drug trafficker can even afford to traffic drugs into United States? Let’s look at the problem. Who is behind this drug trafficking? The bankers? Major bankers? Major business people? And who are those people?Those are the same people that supported him in his candidacy and other people like him in the government. So as far as him wanting to eradicate the drug flow into United States I don’t think so, because that would take away from their pocket book.Undocumented, yeah there is bad apples in there too. And those bad apples, we don’t want them either, we don’t like them either and they should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law.If he wants to talk about violence. Why doesn’t he talk about the children murdered, massacred by his gun trotting hate filled, racist supporters in the United States?JONATHAN GONZALES: We all know our countries have gangs and all that, and of course we know that MS 13 does a lot of bad things. But we all know that in United States more people are killed by the police not the gangs. When a hispanic, black or muslim gets killed, nobody talks about that.But when a white american man kills all these people like the thing that happened in Boston or the discoteque, where all these white men are killing a lot of people. Why isn’t he talking about that? What do they say? -Oh he’s got mental problems-.That is just an excuse.NARRATOR: It is often the innocent who pay the priceROBERT VIVAR: As a father and as a grandfather, you know, there is a lot of children that are being affected. And in every child that I see, I see my grandchild, I see my son I see my daughter. Those fleeing violence, fleeing persecution, extreme poverty, is something that as a human being has to hit home, hit your heart.MARIA: In our country there is a lot of crime. And sometimes you get threatened, even if you didn’t commit a crime. And that is why I protect my face, because if we go on television or anything like that [it would be bad]. They will be watching.If you come here it is because you have troubles back home, due to the gangs, and if they see me, you know…NARRATOR: Many members of the migrant caravan, fleeing gang violence, are in danger if they ever go back; even for some people currently in the US, deportation means a death warrant.JONATHAN GONZALES: When I was in detention I met 3 guys, they I knew that if these guys got deported they would get killed and they are dead already.Because when I was there, I heard that one guy got deported and a day later he got killed. The second one was deported two months ago, at the same time, the other two friends I met over there, got killed the day they returned.NARRATOR: With the Federal Government shut down over the 5 Billion Dollars President Trump has asked for to construct the wall, and the American public polarized even more after the speech, the only thing certain is that more migrants on both sides of the border will continue to suffer.Follow The Real News for more reporting on the issue.
by Oscar León August 26, 2018 for TRNN
A battle for survival; longtime activists-turned candidates like Jovana Renteria are battling with corporate Democrats for control of the party and for the survival of their communities
OSCAR LEON: On November 6, 2018, the state of Arizona will hold its general elections. A generation of young Latina leaders are part of a progressive upswing inside the Democratic Party.
JOVANA RENTERIA: If you would have asked me a long time ago if I would have been running for this position or any elected positions, I would have said no. In the current political climate that we’re in, we have to step up and our community knows we have to. And they are totally in full support in us doing what we’ve got to do. It’s our survival, we have to do anything and everything that we could do to keep our family together. And this is part of running for the judicial system.
OSCAR LEON: Jovana Renteria is a Justice of the Peace Candidate in Phoenix, Arizona. She worked for over a decade with Puente Arizona.
JOVANNA RENTERIA: I’ve fought immigration streamline 27(g), SB 1070. Before this, I worked at domestic violence shelter for 5 years. I recently went to Tornillo to shut down the border and the camp out there that they have with children. I went to San Diego to fight the expansion of streamline.
OSCAR LEON: Along with a group of volunteers, she has covered thousands of homes, knocking on doors and talking to people even in one hundred and ten degrees as it often gets in Phoenix. Her main proposals are to work out a way to keep misdemeanor offenders out of jail, try to work with social services instead of criminalization to resolve conflicts
JOVANNA RENTERIA: We get the minimum. Here in my campaign it’s the minimum that we just have for the mailers and stuff like that. The rest is the community coming through for canvassing, bringing water, bringing food and stuff like that that is actually helping us power our canvassers that are going out every day.
OSCAR LEON: Justice of the Peace is a judicial officer, of small jurisdiction claims, civil cases, traffic violations. All justices hear every type of crime that is considered a misdemeanor, and even some justices of the peace conduct preliminary hearings on felonies.
JOVANNA RENTERIA: They do civil cases and they give all the fines there. People start accumulating fines, they start getting those warrants because they can’t afford them. Family separation starts. So, people don’t understand how important these roles in our communities are.
OSCAR LEON: Renteria sees the high number of criminal codes demanding maximum penalties as a decision to support the prison industrial complex.
JOVANNA RENTERIA: When I decided to actually run, it’s been real for me. My political campaign didn’t start when I submitted my JP application. It started a long time ago when they were criminalizing my grandfather and my tios, now my brothers. You know what I mean? And it’s not something new to me, and I know all these politicians that are directly with these corporations. And I’m here to say that it hasn’t been working, that we need that change, we need a change that’s really going to help our community. Because at the end of the day, our community is the one that’s suffering with family separation.
OSCAR LEON: Renteria thinks that the mistrust between the Latino community and the Phoenix Police Department is a detriment to the city’s safety.
JOVANNA RENTERIA: With the political climate we have been living in under Arpaio, when they were targeting Latinos in different neighborhoods. I think that it’s going to be very hard to trust the police and stuff like that. They are trying to militarize our communities. We don’t need more police, we don’t need to be criminalized more than we already are. if they are not criminalizing us and putting us in jail, they’re shooting us in the streets.
OSCAR LEON: Renteria is one of four candidates for the Justice of the Peace post in Encanto, Phoenix, and in her own words, the one with the smaller budget. None of the other three candidates have any critical statement about Phoenix police department, nor any police accountability proposals on their websites.
JOVANNA RENTERIA: So, there’s a big disconnection that we have with our police department because of how they conduct themselves, on us not trusting them. This year, to this date that we’re currently in today, the Phoenix Police department has killed thirty-three people, our community members. None of them have gone to court, none have gone through a process where they are going to be held accountable for killing our family members. There also hasn’t been a process set forward on handling these situations and deescalating instead of just going to basically shoot, point and kill.
OSCAR LEON: Follow The Real News for more on the fight for community and human rights.
by Oscar León August 27, 2018 for TRNN
A battle for survival: Tired of feeling betrayed and played by career politicians, longtime activists have decided to run for key posts themselves, battling with Corporate Democrats for control of the party
OSCAR LEON: Arizona’s primary election will take place on August 28. Grassroots activist leaders are facing off against corporate Democrats for the party nominations. A generation of mostly Latina leaders are part of the local progressive upswing inside the Democratic Party. Tired of feeling betrayed and played by career politicians, they have decided to run for public office themselves to occupy the positions that can impact their communities.
TERESA MABRY: Sheriff Penzone is actually doing the same thing Sheriff Joe Arpaio did. And so, while there was a name change and a party change, that same politic rests in that office. So, it must be systemic, the issue is systemic.
OSCAR LEON: Teresa Mabry is a candidate for Justice of The Peace in South Phoenix, a district with some of the poorest neighborhoods in the city and with the highest rates of racial diversity.
TERESA MABRY: So, money can buy us signs, money can buy us ads, money can do lots of things with messaging. But that’s not going to change the hearts and minds of what is happening in our communities. Folks want to say like, “Oh, the Democrats were responsible for what happened in Alabama.” No, Black Women led that endeavor and moved and organized to build power.
OSCAR LEON: One of only twelve Movement for Black Lives Electoral Justice Fellows, she has been an activist for over a decade. Born and raised in Guadalupe, queer, Black, Chicana, the granddaughter of Mexican immigrants and a Black community leader, she is at the center of a new vision of politics.
TERESA MABRY: The electability politics. You have to look a certain way, you have to dress a certain way, you need to speak a certain way, your platform needs to have these folks, and you need to have red white and blue as your standard colors, for whatever you put out. And so, we’re challenging these norms because they don’t serve our folks, they don’t serve where we come from.
OSCAR LEON: Maria Castro is running for Governing Board of the Phoenix High School District. She thinks that the same police agents that are killing in the streets should not be in charge of campus security.
MARIA CASTRO: We’ve seen, here in the Phoenix Police Department, how rogue this agency has been, shooting people every five to seven days. And these same officers are within our schools. And we’ve been going to these school board meetings telling the school boards, “Hey, these officers do not mean safety for us, these officers are literally shooting us in the streets, why would you have them on our campuses?”
OSCAR LEON: After being ignored and even belittled, Castro decided to run for the very position that will give her the power to make those changes herself.
MARIA CASTRO: These changes are the ones that need to happen and need to happen by the hand of our own people. And us running allows that to happen and allows us to put an end, to a certain extent, to the bigotry that is happening in the policy, to the ignorance and to the complacency of some of the folks who hold these positions, or are trying to run for these positions, that they do just enough to be called progressives, but don’t actually make the changes necessary that our community needs.
OSCAR LEON: Castro particularly worries about the possibility of the Phoenix Police Department facilitating a path for minors to get deported.
MARIA CASTRO: Right now, with the School Resource Officer Program, officers are allowed to take the student off campus after they are arrested and take them into the county jails where ICE could be potentially waiting for them. So, definitely reducing the amount of police officers that are involved in having student interactions both on campus and off campuses.
OSCAR LEON: Mabry’s platform as Justice of the Peace is to do everything possible to contain the criminalization of the poor by surcharging fines with fees and penalties. This can quickly snowball out of control for those who can’t afford to pay, and eventually send them to prison and to deal with the cost of that imprisonment.
TERESA MABRY: So, not only do you have to pay the warrant fee, you have to pay for your time that you spent in jail, and the payment plan that you couldn’t pay in the first place. And then you have to come and appear in front of the judge. So, now you are missing and paying- you have a list of things that you couldn’t pay in the first place, now you have to go appear in front of the judge, which is more time you have to get off work. So, we’re criminalizing folks who are poor.
OSCAR LEON: Mabry thinks this benefits only those profiting from the prison industrial complex, which in many cases have occupancy quotas that counties and states must meet or face hefty reimbursements. In Arizona, MTC Management & Training Corp, a for-profit private jail corporation, recently got three million dollars from the state after they accepted a settlement on a fifteen-million-dollar lawsuit. The reported quota on its contracts for the prison in Kingman is a ninety-seven-percentage occupancy warranty.
TERESA MABRY: What does it look like, to be value aligned when you can take an endorsement from a police union that covers up murders and the assaults of our community and be really proud of it and not question it. Then we have to look a little bit deeper. We have the highest Black infant mortality rate in the nation in South Phoenix. So, these things, when we think about what’s going on and while or not directly related, but they play into a geopolitical dynamic that exists in South Phoenix. And so, when you cannot be value centered, when you are moving and have the money talk to you in a certain way, it allows you accountability to be questioned. That you are accountable to where that money comes from and not accountable to where you came from and the folks who held you up and got you where you’ve been.
OSCAR LEON: Castro is wary of fake progressives riding the “Blue Wave.”
MARIA CASTRO: You know, time and time again we’ve seen, even on this school board, it’s supposedly the most progressive, but yet continue to ignore our people’s fight. The city council, there’s many Democrats on there, but that doesn’t mean that they represent us the way that they should. And so, again, these people are running for their party, they’re running for their own political gain because the want to “climb” some way. We’re not climbing, we’re building, and we’re building at the base so that our communities can feel stronger, so that our communities have a voice and have a seat at the table.
OSCAR LEON: Teresa Mabry feels the Democratic Party can’t really claim credit for recent progressive victories.
TERESA MABRY: So, we’re not in a flashpoint here with Ocasio Cortez and what’s happening with Stacey Abrams and what’s happening here in Phoenix, this isn’t a flashpoint, this isn’t something that happens randomly. We are actually part of a legacy that has continued to build from the civil rights era and before that.
OSCAR LEON: Castro concludes with a warning about what she sees as career politicians bending their way to power.
MARIA CASTRO: They go up and up and up in their different political positions, and it’s easy for them to climb because they don’t bring community with them. Again, we’re base building, we’re allowing our communities to learn those processes, we’re allowing our communities an opportunity for them to be at the forefront of these changes, for them to be able to dream about what freedom and justice look like in their own terms instead of allowing these other people to just do it on their own. Instead of doing things for them, we’re doing things alongside them.
OSCAR LEON: Follow The Real News for more on the fight for community and human rights.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.